What if understanding the world begins with understanding what shapes the way we see it?
One question per page. Each side’s case, with its sources. Claims the sources contradict are marked, on both sides. No verdict.
The Israeli–Palestinian conflict
15 questions in 7 chapters, ordered by period.
Before you start: why the same events are read so differently →
Antiquity to today
The land and its peoples
How Israelis and Palestinians interpret the land’s history, and how those interpretations shape their competing claims today.
- Who is indigenous to the land, and what claim does that give?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can ancestry three thousand years old outweigh the claim of a people who lived on the land, as its majority, for centuries?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can a people that took shape in this land, and never wholly left it, be called colonisers when it returns?
- Who is indigenous to the land, and what claim does that give?
1947 to today
The 1948 war and the exodus
Why hundreds of thousands left their homes in 1948, and what has become of their claims since.
- Why did hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs leave their homes in 1947–1949: were they mainly expelled, or did they mainly flee?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can a population that left under attack, and was then barred from returning, be said to have left of its own accord?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can a population that left a war its own side started be said to have been driven out by the other?
- Do the Palestinians who left or were driven out in 1947–1949, and their descendants, have a right to return to what is now Israel?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can people driven from their homes lose the right to go back because they have been kept out for generations?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can a recommendation made in 1948 give millions of descendants, born elsewhere, a right to settle in Israel?
- Why did hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs leave their homes in 1947–1949: were they mainly expelled, or did they mainly flee?
1948 to today
Statehood and recognition
Who recognises whom, in what words, and what each side offered in the talks for a peace agreement.
- Have the Palestinians accepted Israel’s existence, and in what terms?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Why should the 1993 recognition be enough, when the PLO refuses Israel as a Jewish state and Hamas rejects any recognition?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Why should the 1993 recognition not be enough, when the PLO, not Hamas, speaks for the Palestinians, and refusing the words “Jewish state” is not refusing the state?
- Why did the peace talks of 2000 to 2008 end without an agreement?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
If the proposals came orally or without a map, while settlements grew and Israel’s leaders faced elections or resignation, who walked away from peace?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
If Israel’s proposals of 2000 and 2008 offered a state on most of the West Bank and Gaza and were never accepted, who walked away from peace?
- Have the Palestinians accepted Israel’s existence, and in what terms?
1960s to today
The language of armed conflict
Whether attacks by Palestinian armed groups are resistance or terrorism, and what each side calls them.
- Should Hamas’s actions be considered resistance or terrorism?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can the deliberate killing of civilians ever be called resistance?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can a people’s armed struggle against occupation be called terrorism as a whole, when the laws of war allow attacks on soldiers?
- Should Hamas’s actions be considered resistance or terrorism?
1967 to today
Land and law since 1967
What Israel’s control of the territories it took in 1967 means in law.
- Are Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, lawful under international law?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can the ban on transferring civilians exempt an occupying power that settles its own people in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, occupied since 1967?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can the ban on transferring civilians apply to Israelis who choose to settle in Judea and Samaria, land with no recognised sovereign before 1967?
- What changed Palestinians’ lives in the West Bank and Gaza from the 1970s to the 2000s?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
If the closures began before the suicide bombings and outlasted every attack, what were they for?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
If Palestinians moved and worked freely until the stabbings and suicide bombings began, what closed the gates?
- What shaped the Gaza Strip between 2005, when Israel removed its settlements and soldiers, and October 2023?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
When a territory left without soldiers or settlers is taken over by an armed group that fires on its neighbour, who is responsible for what follows?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
When a power keeps a territory’s borders, sea and sky, and restricts what goes in and out, who is responsible for what follows?
- Are Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, lawful under international law?
1990s to today
How each people sees the other
What each people believes about the other, how opinion divides within each, and what its children are taught.
Within each society: how opinion divides among Israelis and among Palestinians →
- Where do most Israelis and most Palestinians stand on compromise with the other side?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
If most Palestinians approved of 7 October and reject two states, who on their side is ready for peace?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
If Israel’s government, parliament and most Israeli Jews reject a Palestinian state, who on their side is ready for peace?
- What are Israeli and Palestinian children taught about the other people, and has it changed?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
If Israeli schoolbooks leave the 1967 line off their maps, and the word Nakba was removed from an Arabic school book, what are Israeli children taught about Palestinians?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
If Palestinian schoolbooks present attacks as heroic resistance and show maps without Israel, what are Palestinian children taught about Israel?
- Where do most Israelis and most Palestinians stand on compromise with the other side?
2023 to today
The war in Gaza
The war that began with the attack of 7 October 2023, and what the courts have said.
- What happened on 7 October 2023, and how do the two sides account for it?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
If the attack was designed to kill civilians and take hostages, can any grievance justify 7 October?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
If the attack came after decades of occupation and blockade, and some of what was said about it was false, can 7 October be understood without its context?
- Is Israel’s military campaign in Gaza genocide, as international law defines it?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Is a war to defeat Hamas and free the hostages, against an enemy hidden among civilians, genocide?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Are mass killing, destruction, and starvation, together with what Israel’s leaders said, genocide?
- What has the International Court of Justice decided in South Africa’s genocide case against Israel?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Did the Court find Gazans’ right to protection from genocide at real risk, and place Israel under binding orders, including a halt to its offensive in Rafah?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Did the Court find the accusation of genocide plausible, or impose on Israel anything beyond its existing obligations?
- Who is responsible for the suffering of Gaza’s civilians, and to what extent?
Framed in support of Israel’s position
Can a movement that started the war, and fought from among civilians, escape responsibility for what followed?
Framed in support of the Palestinian position
Can an army that controls the bombing and the crossings blame another party for the suffering that follows?
- What happened on 7 October 2023, and how do the two sides account for it?
From the editor
Our identities, histories, and experiences influence how we see the world, whose stories we trust, and how we understand those who see things differently.
Side by Side is a personal journey to explore different perspectives, question my own assumptions, and better understand the space where our worlds meet.