Do Israelis and Palestinians each speak with one voice?
Last reviewed
In brief
Within Israeli society
Israeli society is divided: asked to choose one outcome, Israeli Jews split between annexation and two states, and more than a quarter do not know; the religious and the secular, the right and the left answer far apart; Arab citizens of Israel answer differently again.
Asked to choose one outcome in 2026, 42% of Israeli Jews chose annexation and 26% two states, while 64% of Arab citizens chose two states. Support for two states among Jews runs from 36% of the secular to 1% of the Haredim, and from 80% on the left to 6% on the right.
Sources: [1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
Palestinians are divided between two states, a confederation and one state, and Gaza and the West Bank, Hamas and Fatah supporters, and the young answer differently.
In 2026, 44% supported two states in principle and 50% opposed them; 56% supported a specific two-state formula on the 1967 lines. Asked the most effective path toward “ending occupation and establishing a Palestinian state”, 42% chose negotiations and 33% armed struggle. A third chose none of the parties offered, and Palestinians have not voted nationally since 2006.
Sources: [3]Public Opinion Poll No (97), August 2026(opens another site in a new tab)[4]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab)
About this page: Each question page sets out two cases, but neither society holds one view. This page shows how opinion divides within each: the figures from the most comparable surveys available, with their differences stated; the words of people from different camps; and what the pollsters themselves say their results mean. Why people hold their views is the subject of the guide “Why do Israelis and Palestinians read the same events so differently?”.
A disagreement about facts
The two sides disagree about what happened. Each factual claim can be checked against its sources.
Point by point
Point 1 of 10
What settlement do people want?
Both peoples were asked the same questions in the joint poll of July 2024; the other figures come from separate surveys and are marked as such.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024, the same questions asked of both peoples: among Israeli Jews, 21% supported two states (34% in 2022, 42% in 2020), 14% one state with equal rights, and 12% a confederation; 42% supported annexing the West Bank without equal rights for Palestinians.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Among Arab citizens of Israel, in the same poll, 72% supported two states and 49% one state with equal rights.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
By religious observance, support for two states among Israeli Jews was 36% of the secular, 17% of the traditional, 3% of the national-religious and 1% of the Haredim (joint poll, 2024). By political camp, it was 80% on the left, 39% in the centre, 16% on the moderate right and 6% on the right (Peace Index, July 2026, among those with an opinion).
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab)[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
A different question, Peace Index, July 2026: asked to choose one outcome, 42% of Israeli Jews chose annexation, 26% two states and 5% a binational state; 27% did not know. Among Arab citizens, 64% chose two states.
[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Bezalel Smotrich
As finance minister, in 2024: “My life’s mission is to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state.”
[5]Israeli far-right minister Bezalel Smotrich sets out plan to annex West Bank(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yair Lapid
As opposition leader, in 2025: “There will not be a two-state solution in the next decade because of what happened after October 7”
[6]Lapid at MEAD conference(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yair Golan
The leader of the Democrats, the merged Labor and Meretz party, in 2025: “If we do not separate ourselves from the Palestinians, the alternative is annexation, and that is a catastrophe for Israel.”
[7]Yair Golan on Netanyahu, Israel’s ‘tribalism’ and believing in a two-state solution(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Joint poll authors
The joint poll’s authors write that the fall in Israeli Jewish support is “a trend that began in December 2022 and pre-dates the war”.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Peace Index authors
The Peace Index’s authors, Nimrod Rosler and Alon Yakter, in 2025: “the decline in support for the two-state solution is not accompanied by an increase in support for any alternative long-term solution.”
[8]The Peace Index, March 2025(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Gadi Eisenkot
The leader of Yashar!, the second-largest list in the 2026 Knesset, during the campaign: “My position on the Palestinian issue has remained consistent: The principle of two states for two peoples is a mistake.”
[9]Israel’s election: The main issues in the words of the leading candidates(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024, the same questions: among Palestinians, 40% supported two states (33% in 2022, 43% in 2020), 25% one state with equal rights, and 35% a confederation, up from 22% in 2022, a rise the pollsters say “comes mostly from the Gaza Strip”.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
By party, support for two states was 65% among likely voters of third parties, 42% among Fatah’s and 29% among Hamas supporters (joint poll, 2024).
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
A different question, PCPSR, August 2026: support for two states was 44% in principle, with 50% against; for a specific two-state formula on the 1967 lines it was 56% (61% in Gaza). A confederation received 14% and one state with equal rights 10%.
[3]Public Opinion Poll No (97), August 2026(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mahmoud Abbas
At the UN in 2024, the president of the Palestinian Authority and the PLO called for “the independence of the Palestinian state on the borders of June 4, 1967, with East Jerusalem as its capital”.
[10]Full text of President Abbas’s speech at the UN General Assembly, 26 September 2024 (unofficial translation)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mustafa Barghouti
The leader of the Palestinian National Initiative, in 2024: “We can live together in one democratic state.” And: “It’s up to the Israelis if the future will be two states or one state.”
[11]Mustafa Barghouti, former Palestinian minister: ‘We can live together in one democratic state’(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khaled Meshaal
The Hamas leader, in 2024: “The West says that October 7 has opened up prospects for a political vision, so they have returned to talk about their old commodity, which is the two-state solution.”
[12]Meshaal: Hamas rejects two-state solution(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mohammed El-Kurd
A writer from Sheikh Jarrah, born in 1998, in 2023: “I don’t think there’s a geography in which a two state solution is possible.” Whatever the arrangement (“one state, two state, 48 states”), he says, “refugees need to return, land needs to be given back, wealth needs to be redistributed, and a recognition of the Nakba needs to happen.”
[13]Transcript for Mohammed El-Kurd: Palestine | Lex Fridman Podcast #391(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khalil Shikaki
The director of PCPSR writes that “The Palestinian constituency most opposed to the two-state solution includes supporters of Hamas and the youth”, and that the young people’s opposition “is based neither on religion nor on ideology”.
[14]Critical Policy Brief 3/2024: Did October the 7th and the Gaza War put an end to the two-state solution?(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Haidar Eid
A professor at al-Aqsa University in Gaza, in a book excerpt published in 2024 while he lived there through the war: “we start seriously thinking about a futuristic vision in historic Palestine where all people are treated equally in one state, a secular, democratic state for all regardless of religion and ethnicity.”
[15]‘This book is being published while Gaza, where I live, is being annihilated’—Read an excerpt from Decolonising the Palestinian Mind by South African–Palestinian author Haidar Eid(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Within Israeli society
Among Israeli Jews, support for two states has halved since 2020, from 42% to 21% in 2024. The pollsters say the fall began in December 2022, before the war; the opposition leader Yair Lapid said in 2025 that there would be no two states in the next decade “because of what happened after October 7”. Annexation without equal rights for Palestinians drew 42% in 2024, yet among those with an opinion support for two states still ran from 80% on the left to 6% on the right in 2026. Gadi Eisenkot, who leads the second-largest list in the new Knesset, calls the principle of two states a mistake. Arab citizens of Israel remain strongly in favour.
Within Palestinian society
Support for two states fell from 43% in 2020 to 33% in 2022, then rose to 40% in 2024; in a different question in 2026, 56% supported a specific two-state formula on the 1967 lines. A confederation gained ground between 2022 and 2024, mostly in Gaza according to the pollsters, and Khalil Shikaki finds Hamas supporters and the young the most opposed to two states.
Point 2 of 10
Violence, armed struggle and negotiations
The two peoples were asked different questions here: Israelis whether they support negotiations, Palestinians which means work best.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Peace Index, July 2026: 29% of Israeli Jews supported negotiations with the Palestinian Authority. Among Arab citizens, 81% did. Among Jews with an opinion, 83% of the left and 54% of the centre supported them, against 22% of the moderate right and 7% of the right.
[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yair Lapid
As opposition leader, in 2025, on the effect of 7 October: “the burden of proof moved from us to the Palestinians”
[6]Lapid at MEAD conference(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mansour Abbas
The leader of Ra’am, an Islamist party of Arab citizens that joined a government coalition: “the armed Palestinian factions need to stop using weapons and turn to a diplomatic project”.
[16]Mansour Abbas on the armed factions(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
PCPSR, October 2026, asked the most effective path toward “ending occupation and establishing a Palestinian state”: 42% said negotiations, 33% armed struggle and 18% popular non-violent resistance. Support for armed struggle rose in Gaza from 21% to 37% in two months, and fell in the West Bank from 32% to 29%.
[17]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab)[4]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mustafa Barghouti
The leader of the Palestinian National Initiative, in 2024: “Those who oppose armed resistance oppose any form of resistance, not only armed resistance.”
[18]Mustafa Barghouti reflects on the future of the Palestinian struggle(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khaled Meshaal
The head of Hamas abroad, in February 2026, rejecting disarmament: “Resistance is a right for people under occupation; it is part of international law and the heavenly religions.”
[19]Hamas leader rejects disarmament while Israeli occupation of Gaza continues(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·PCPSR
PCPSR says the rise in Gaza was “probably driven by the Israeli non-stop daily strikes in that area”, and reads its August 2026 results as suggesting that “Palestinians may be moving toward a more pragmatic conception of conflict resolution”.
[17]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab)[3]Public Opinion Poll No (97), August 2026(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Arab Center Washington DC
Arab Center Washington DC, outside the polling teams, argues that the fall in support for armed struggle “most likely does not signal declining support for challenging Israel”.
[20]Reading Palestinian Polls—and Misreading Palestinian Politics(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Nasser al-Kidwa
A former Palestinian foreign minister, outside Fatah since 2021, in 2024: “We, as Palestinians, are still prepared and prefer that this national independence is achieved peacefully and through negotiations. However, these negotiations require a clear Israeli agreement on the principle of two states—Palestine and Israel—on the 1967 borders.”
[21]The Palestinian strategy in confronting the Israeli strategy(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Marwan Barghouti
The imprisoned Fatah leader, in an article in 2015: “There can be no negotiations without a clear Israeli commitment to fully withdraw from the Palestinian territory it occupied in 1967, including East Jerusalem”.
[22]There will be no peace until Israel’s occupation of Palestine ends(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Within Israeli society
Fewer than a third of Israeli Jews supported negotiations with the Palestinian Authority in July 2026; among those with an opinion, most of the left and centre were in favour and few on the right. 81% of Arab citizens of Israel were in favour, and Mansour Abbas, an Arab citizen of Israel, urges the Palestinian factions to lay down their arms.
Within Palestinian society
Asked a different question, Palestinians put negotiations ahead of armed struggle as the best path, 42% to 33%, but the balance shifted in late 2026: support for armed struggle fell in the West Bank and rose sharply in Gaza, a rise PCPSR thinks was probably driven by Israeli strikes there. Hamas calls resistance a right; Mustafa Barghouti says that those who oppose armed resistance oppose any resistance; Nasser al-Kidwa and, in 2015, Marwan Barghouti make negotiations conditional on Israel accepting a withdrawal to the 1967 lines.
Point 3 of 10
Religion
The surveys cited here did not ask both peoples the same question about religion; the figures measure different things, years apart.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Pew, 2014–15: 61% of Israeli Jews said God gave the land of Israel to the Jewish people. Those who did not believe in God or did not know, 27%, were not asked.
[23]Israel’s Religiously Divided Society: views of the Jewish state and the diaspora(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mansour Abbas
The leader of Ra’am: “Religion does not need to be what separates us, it can be the thing that brings us together”.
[24]Mansour Abbas’ political gambit(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Michael Melchior
An Orthodox rabbi and former minister who works for religious peacemaking, in 2026: “The Israeli left and the Palestinian left were too narrow to hold the peace. You cannot make peace without the religious, traditional element as a main part of it.”
[25]Rabbi Michael Melchior in Conversation with Sruli Fruchter(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yaakov Medan
A head of the Har Etzion yeshiva and a senior religious-Zionist rabbi, after Israeli riots in Palestinian towns in 2023: “when we do something so immoral as this, we lose our moral right to settle in this land.”
[26]Religious Zionist Rabbi praises ISA for protecting Palestinians(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
PCPSR, June 2022: 45% of Palestinians said the conflict had become religious, and 53% that it was still over land and sovereignty. The religious answer was given by 51% in Gaza and 41% in the West Bank.
[27]Public Opinion Poll No (84), June 2022(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mahmoud Abbas
The president of the Palestinian Authority, in 2022: “our conflict with the occupation is essentially a political conflict and not a conflict with a particular religion.”
[28]President Abbas: Jerusalem is not for sale(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
The two peoples have not been asked the same question, so the figures cannot be compared directly.
Within Israeli society
In 2014–15, 61% of Israeli Jews said God gave the land of Israel to the Jewish people. Rabbi Michael Melchior argues that peace needs the religious and traditional element, and Rabbi Yaakov Medan ties the right to settle the land to moral conduct. Mansour Abbas, an Arab citizen of Israel, says religion can bring people together.
Within Palestinian society
In 2022, 45% of Palestinians saw the conflict as having become religious and 53% as still about land and sovereignty, Gazans more often seeing it as religious. Mahmoud Abbas calls the conflict political.
Point 4 of 10
Refugees and return
Both peoples were asked about the same compromise in the joint poll of July 2024.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024: 8% of Israeli Jews supported a refugee arrangement in which Israel takes back about 100,000 Palestinians through family unification and the other refugees are compensated (11% in 2022). Among Arab citizens of Israel, 62% supported it.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
In the same poll, 57% of Palestinians supported the arrangement (67% in Gaza, 52% in the West Bank), up from 37% in 2022.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In PCPSR’s 2003 surveys of refugees, asked to choose among options that included return to Israel “in accordance with an annual quota”, 12% of refugees in the West Bank and Gaza, 5% in Jordan and 23% in Lebanon, 10% in all, made return to Israel their first choice.
[29]Results of PSR refugees’ polls in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Jordan and Lebanon (2003)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mahmoud Abbas
The president of the Palestinian Authority, in 2023, called for “resolving the issue of Palestinian refugees in accordance with United Nations Resolution No. 194”.
[30]President Abbas’s speech at the Cairo Summit for Peace, 21 October 2023(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Faisal Salameh
An official of the Tulkarem refugee camp’s popular committee, in 2026, after Israeli raids on West Bank camps: “Israel has turned the camp into an environment that drives residents away”.
[31]Palestinians dream of returning home after Israel raids West Bank camps(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Both peoples were asked in 2024 about a compromise bringing about 100,000 refugees back to Israel through family unification and compensating the rest.
Within Israeli society
8% of Israeli Jews backed it; a majority of Arab citizens of Israel did.
Within Palestinian society
A majority of Palestinians backed it, up from just over a third in 2022. Mahmoud Abbas frames return in terms of UN Resolution 194, and a camp official describes Israeli raids in 2026 driving residents out of the West Bank camps. The only survey of refugees’ own choices cited here dates from 2003, when 10% of refugees made return to Israel their first choice.
Point 5 of 10
Jerusalem
Both peoples were asked about the same arrangement in the joint poll of July 2024.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024: 14% of Israeli Jews supported West Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and East Jerusalem as Palestine’s; 62% of Arab citizens of Israel did.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Ehud Olmert
The former prime minister, presenting a joint plan with Nasser al-Kidwa in 2024, proposed “the Arab side of Jerusalem, which will become the Palestinian capital”.
[32]Amanpour, 29 October 2024 (transcript)(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
In the same poll, 24% of Palestinians supported that arrangement (36% in Gaza, 16% in the West Bank), up from 16% in 2022.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Nasser al-Kidwa
The former Palestinian foreign minister, presenting the same plan, said that Jerusalem “should be the capital of both”.
[32]Amanpour, 29 October 2024 (transcript)(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Two capitals in Jerusalem has little support in either people, though in 2024 a former Israeli prime minister and a former Palestinian foreign minister presented it together.
Within Israeli society
About one in seven Israeli Jews support it. Arab citizens of Israel are the exception, with a majority in favour.
Within Palestinian society
About one in four Palestinians support it; support has risen since 2022 and is highest in Gaza.
Point 6 of 10
Trust
Both peoples were asked the same question in the joint poll of July 2024.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024: 10% of Israeli Jews thought Palestinians were trustworthy (11% in 2022). Among Arab citizens of Israel, 64% thought Israeli Jews could be trusted.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Nimrod Rosler
Of Tel Aviv University’s Peace Index, in 2023: “Both sides see themselves overwhelmingly – 84 percent – as the exclusive victim, which leads each side to support violent solutions”.
[33]Haaretz on the joint poll, January 2023 (republished by Tel Aviv University)(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
In the same poll, 6% of Palestinians thought Israeli Jews were trustworthy.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khalil Shikaki
The director of PCPSR, in 2024: “The current level of distrust, about 90% or higher, is the highest ever recorded in the joint surveys since 2016”. He adds that the change “reflects greater fear and pain that can be reduced by calculated policy change by the leaders of the two sides.”
[14]Critical Policy Brief 3/2024: Did October the 7th and the Gaza War put an end to the two-state solution?(opens another site in a new tab)[34]Critical Policy Brief 3/2024 (full text)(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Khalil Shikaki calls the distrust between the two peoples the highest recorded in the joint surveys.
Within Israeli society
One in ten Israeli Jews say Palestinians can be trusted. Arab citizens of Israel are the exception: most say Israeli Jews can be trusted. Nimrod Rosler points to each side seeing itself as the only victim.
Within Palestinian society
Fewer than one in ten Palestinians say Israeli Jews can be trusted. Shikaki ties the distrust to fear and pain that leaders’ decisions could reduce.
Point 7 of 10
Settlements and the West Bank
The joint poll of 2024 asked both peoples about the same compromise; the other figures come from separate surveys.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Peace Index, July 2026: 63% of Israeli Jews supported expanding Jewish settlement in the West Bank on the ground of the Jewish people’s right to the land, and 66% on the ground of security. Among Arab citizens, 10% did.
[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Joint poll, July 2024: 21% of Israeli Jews and 55% of Arab citizens supported a Palestinian state in which Israel keeps blocs of settlements in an equal land swap and evacuates all other settlements.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yossi Dagan
The head of the Samaria Regional Council, a leader of the settlers, to the prime minister in 2025, calling for “full sovereignty over all the communities and open areas”.
[35]Samaria Council head to PM: ‘Total victory is sovereignty’(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Aryeh Deri
The leader of Shas, a Haredi party, in 2024, said that talk of returning settlers to Gaza “causes serious harm to Judea and Samaria and unnecessarily raises the Palestinian issue again”.
[36]Deri: Talk of returning settlers to Gaza causes serious harm(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yair Lapid
As opposition leader, proposing a regional arrangement in 2024: “Israel would commit not to annex the West Bank.”
[37]Yair Lapid: a regional arrangement for Israel and the Middle East(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Peace Index authors
The Peace Index’s authors, Nimrod Rosler and Alon Yakter, in 2026: “It is the security rationale that succeeds in mobilizing a degree of support beyond the right-wing bloc.”
[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Naftali Bennett
The leader of Together, in June 2026, backing legal building in Area C and opposing illegal outposts (“What is not legal will not be”): “Ultimately Area C will be part of the State of Israel; Areas A and B will be part of the Palestinian autonomy.”
[38]האמירה של בנט שמסעירה את הימין(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
In the same 2024 poll, 34% of Palestinians supported the blocs-and-evacuation arrangement (47% in Gaza, 25% in the West Bank). PCPSR, August 2026: 58% said settlement expansion had made two states no longer practical.
[2]Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork)(opens another site in a new tab)[3]Public Opinion Poll No (97), August 2026(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Hanan Ashrawi
As a member of the PLO Executive Committee, in 2020: “Stopping annexation and ending the occupation is a moral imperative”.
[39]Ashrawi welcomes global call by international women leaders against Israeli annexation(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khalil Shikaki
The director of PCPSR, in 2024, writes that support for two states among both peoples began to decline after the talks collapsed in 2014: “The main driver for the decline at that time was the belief, shared by both sides, that the two-state solution was no longer practical or feasible given the changes on the ground, such as settlement expansion”.
[14]Critical Policy Brief 3/2024: Did October the 7th and the Gaza War put an end to the two-state solution?(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Within Israeli society
Most Israeli Jews support expanding settlement in the West Bank, whether the reason given is the right to the land or security, and the Peace Index’s authors find that the security argument reaches beyond the right. Settler leaders call for full sovereignty; Naftali Bennett, who leads Together, sees Area C becoming part of Israel and opposes illegal outposts; the opposition leader Yair Lapid has proposed a commitment not to annex; and the leader of Shas, a Haredi party, warned against reopening Gaza to settlers. A compromise keeping the large blocs and evacuating the rest wins a minority of Israeli Jews.
Within Palestinian society
The same compromise wins a minority of Palestinians, and most say expansion has already made two states impractical. Khalil Shikaki names that belief, shared by both sides, as the main driver of the decline in support for two states after 2014.
Point 8 of 10
The war since 7 October 2023
The two peoples were asked about different parts of the war’s end.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Peace Index, July 2026: 47% of Israeli Jews supported President Trump’s plan to end the war in Gaza, down from 61% in November 2025; among Arab citizens, 54%. The plan provides for a technocratic Palestinian government, Hamas’s disarmament and a gradual Israeli withdrawal. A proposal to hand authority to the Palestinian government of experts and an international force before disarming Hamas was supported by 27% of Israeli Jews and opposed by 57%.
[1]The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings(opens another site in a new tab)[40]The Peace Index, July 2026: findings(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Benjamin Netanyahu
As prime minister, in 2025: “our opposition to a Palestinian state on any territory west of the Jordan River remains firm and unchanged”
[41]Netanyahu at the cabinet meeting, 26 October 2025(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Aryeh Deri
The leader of Shas, in December 2023, on the Palestinian Authority governing Gaza: “They should first be able to rule Judea and Samaria. They don't have the capabilities for that.”
[42]MK Deri: When we achieve our goals - we will stay in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
PCPSR, October 2026: 42% of Palestinians trusted the proposed technocratic committee to run Gaza (60% in Gaza, 29% in the West Bank), and 74% opposed Hamas disarming before a complete Israeli withdrawal.
[4]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·PCPSR
PCPSR reads these answers as “balanced strategic realism”.
[4]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Basem Naim
A member of Hamas’s political bureau, in 2024: “We are not willing to come back to govern the Gaza Strip”
[43]A Hamas leader says they will give up governing Gaza but won’t lay down arms(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Dahlia Scheindlin
Of the joint poll’s team, in 2026, reading the fall in support for Hamas: “a sign of anger against the group for the consequences of the wars.”
[44]Interview – Dahlia Scheindlin(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yousef Munayyer
Of Arab Center Washington DC, outside the polling teams, reading the same fall differently: “disappointment in Hamas for appearing to retreat from its commitment to resistance by accepting the principle of disarmament.”
[20]Reading Palestinian Polls—and Misreading Palestinian Politics(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
Within Israeli society
Support among Israeli Jews for President Trump’s plan to end the war fell from 61% in November 2025 to 47% in July 2026, and 57% opposed handing Gaza to a Palestinian government of experts before Hamas is disarmed. The prime minister rules out a Palestinian state west of the Jordan.
Within Palestinian society
Gazans were far more willing than West Bankers to trust the proposed technocratic committee, 60% to 29%, and 74% of Palestinians opposed Hamas disarming before a complete Israeli withdrawal. Hamas’s standing in PCPSR’s polls fell from 35% to 19% in the ten months to October 2026; Dahlia Scheindlin reads it as anger at the cost of the wars, Yousef Munayyer as disappointment at Hamas accepting disarmament in principle.
Point 9 of 10
Who speaks for each people?
Israelis voted in October 2026; Palestinians last voted nationally in 2006.
Within Israeli society
- Factual claim
Israel held a general election on 27 October 2026. Official results by seats: Likud 27, Yashar! 21, Together 12, Joint List 11, the Democrats 8, Ra’am 8, Yisrael Beytenu 7, Otzma Yehudit 7, United Torah Judaism 7, Shas 6, Religious Zionism–Zehut 6.
[45]Results of the Elections for the 26th Knesset: National Results(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Ayman Odeh
The leader of Hadash–Ta’al, an Arab citizens’ party, on Jewish–Arab politics: “You can’t beat the right without us.”
[46]Ayman Odeh: ‘You can’t beat the right without us’(opens another site in a new tab)
Within Palestinian society
- Factual claim
In January 2006, the last Palestinian national legislative election, Hamas won 74 of 132 seats and Fatah 45. In 2021, President Abbas postponed the elections that had been called.
[47]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank (background)(opens another site in a new tab)[48]Palestinian leader delays parliamentary and presidential elections, blaming Israel(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
PCPSR, October 2026: 22% of Palestinians supported Fatah and 19% Hamas (13% in the West Bank); 33% chose “None of the Above”, 48% in the West Bank and 11% in Gaza. Among likely voters offered nine lists, an independent list led by the businessman Bashar Masri and a list backed by the imprisoned Fatah leader Marwan Barghouti tied at 22% each.
[4]October 2026 Election Poll(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Ismail Haniyeh
The then Hamas leader said that “the postponement of the elections would mean the confiscation of the political rights of the Palestinians”.
[49]Hamas chief: delaying elections has no credible justification(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khalil Shikaki
The director of PCPSR, in 2024: “In the West Bank, 92% are now demanding his resignation”, of President Abbas; and, on Hamas’s earlier rise, “The act itself of resorting to armed struggle in the eyes of the Palestinians was enough for them to support Hamas”.
[50]In the West Bank, an independent Palestine remains a distant dream(opens another site in a new tab)[51]Shikaki on support for Hamas(opens another site in a new tab)
In short
The two peoples’ political voices rest on very different footing.
Within Israeli society
Israelis elected a new Knesset in October 2026, in which Arab-led parties hold 19 of 120 seats.
Within Palestinian society
Palestinians last elected a legislature in 2006; the elections called for 2021 were postponed, and in October 2026 a third of Palestinians, almost half in the West Bank, chose none of the parties on offer. Asked about nine possible lists, likely voters put an independent list and one backed by the imprisoned Marwan Barghouti level in first place. In 2024, Khalil Shikaki reported that 92% of West Bankers wanted President Abbas to resign.
Point 10 of 10
Who works across the line?
Some organisations bring members of both peoples together. They describe themselves in their own words below; how many people share their views is not measured here.
- Position ·Standing Together
Standing Together describes itself as “organizing Jewish and Palestinian citizens of Israel against the occupation”.
[52]Standing Together(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Combatants for Peace
Combatants for Peace, former Israeli soldiers and Palestinian fighters: “we have been committed to nonviolence since our inception.”
[53]There is another way(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Parents Circle–Families Forum
The Parents Circle–Families Forum, Israeli and Palestinian families who lost relatives in the conflict, calls itself “a force for reconciliation, dialogue, and peace.”
[54]About PCFF(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·A Land for All
A Land for All, a joint Israeli–Palestinian movement, proposes two states in one shared homeland, affirming “the equal right of both nations to self-determination”.
[55]A Land for All: Two States, One Homeland(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Khalil Shikaki
The director of PCPSR, in 2024: “the two publics are not an impediment to peace based on the two-state solution. The two peoples are certainly not a force for peace”. The joint poll’s authors write that incentives “remain capable of reversing the hardline views”.
[14]Critical Policy Brief 3/2024: Did October the 7th and the Gaza War put an end to the two-state solution?(opens another site in a new tab)[56]Joint press release on the July 2024 Palestinian-Israeli Pulse(opens another site in a new tab)
In short: How many people share these organisations’ views is not measured here. Their members include former fighters and bereaved families from both peoples, and Arab and Jewish citizens of Israel. The authors of the joint poll find that incentives can move both publics towards a peace package, and Khalil Shikaki writes that the publics “are not an impediment to peace”, even if they are not “a force for peace”.
Sources
- The Peace Index, July 2026: summary of findings (opens another site)Tel Aviv University
- Palestinian-Israeli Pulse: A Joint Poll, summary report (July 2024 fieldwork) (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research and Tel Aviv University
- Public Opinion Poll No (97), August 2026 (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- October 2026 Election Poll (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- Israeli far-right minister Bezalel Smotrich sets out plan to annex West Bank (opens another site)The Guardian
- Lapid at MEAD conference (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
- Yair Golan on Netanyahu, Israel’s ‘tribalism’ and believing in a two-state solution (opens another site)The Jewish Independent
- The Peace Index, March 2025 (opens another site)Tel Aviv University
- Israel’s election: The main issues in the words of the leading candidates (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- Full text of President Abbas’s speech at the UN General Assembly, 26 September 2024 (unofficial translation) (opens another site)Embassy of the State of Palestine to the Holy See
- Mustafa Barghouti, former Palestinian minister: ‘We can live together in one democratic state’ (opens another site)El País
- Meshaal: Hamas rejects two-state solution (opens another site)Middle East Monitor
- Transcript for Mohammed El-Kurd: Palestine | Lex Fridman Podcast #391 (opens another site)Lex Fridman Podcast
- Critical Policy Brief 3/2024: Did October the 7th and the Gaza War put an end to the two-state solution? (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- ‘This book is being published while Gaza, where I live, is being annihilated’—Read an excerpt from Decolonising the Palestinian Mind by South African–Palestinian author Haidar Eid (opens another site)The Johannesburg Review of Books
- Mansour Abbas on the armed factions (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
- October 2026 Election Poll (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- Mustafa Barghouti reflects on the future of the Palestinian struggle (opens another site)Mondoweiss
- Hamas leader rejects disarmament while Israeli occupation of Gaza continues (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- Reading Palestinian Polls—and Misreading Palestinian Politics (opens another site)Arab Center Washington DC
- The Palestinian strategy in confronting the Israeli strategy (opens another site)Al Majalla
- There will be no peace until Israel’s occupation of Palestine ends (opens another site)The Guardian
- Israel’s Religiously Divided Society: views of the Jewish state and the diaspora (opens another site)Pew Research Center
- Mansour Abbas’ political gambit (opens another site)Jewish Insider
- Rabbi Michael Melchior in Conversation with Sruli Fruchter (opens another site)Rabbi Michael Melchior (official website)
- Religious Zionist Rabbi praises ISA for protecting Palestinians (opens another site)Israel National News
- Public Opinion Poll No (84), June 2022 (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- President Abbas: Jerusalem is not for sale (opens another site)WAFA (Palestinian news agency)
- Results of PSR refugees’ polls in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Jordan and Lebanon (2003) (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- President Abbas’s speech at the Cairo Summit for Peace, 21 October 2023 (opens another site)WAFA (Palestinian news agency)
- Palestinians dream of returning home after Israel raids West Bank camps (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- Amanpour, 29 October 2024 (transcript) (opens another site)CNN
- Haaretz on the joint poll, January 2023 (republished by Tel Aviv University) (opens another site)Tel Aviv University
- Critical Policy Brief 3/2024 (full text) (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
- Samaria Council head to PM: ‘Total victory is sovereignty’ (opens another site)Israel National News
- Deri: Talk of returning settlers to Gaza causes serious harm (opens another site)Israel National News
- Yair Lapid: a regional arrangement for Israel and the Middle East (opens another site)The National
- האמירה של בנט שמסעירה את הימין (opens another site)Israel National News
- Ashrawi welcomes global call by international women leaders against Israeli annexation (opens another site)WAFA (Palestinian news agency)
- The Peace Index, July 2026: findings (opens another site)Tel Aviv University
- Netanyahu at the cabinet meeting, 26 October 2025 (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
- MK Deri: When we achieve our goals - we will stay in Gaza (opens another site)Israel National News
- A Hamas leader says they will give up governing Gaza but won’t lay down arms (opens another site)OPB
- Interview – Dahlia Scheindlin (opens another site)E-International Relations
- Results of the Elections for the 26th Knesset: National Results (opens another site)Central Elections Committee for the Knesset
- Ayman Odeh: ‘You can’t beat the right without us’ (opens another site)Prospect
- Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank (background) (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Palestinian leader delays parliamentary and presidential elections, blaming Israel (opens another site)Reuters, published by Egypt Independent
- Hamas chief: delaying elections has no credible justification (opens another site)Anadolu Agency
- In the West Bank, an independent Palestine remains a distant dream (opens another site)CNN
- Shikaki on support for Hamas (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
- Standing Together (opens another site)Standing Together
- There is another way (opens another site)Combatants for Peace
- About PCFF (opens another site)Parents Circle–Families Forum
- A Land for All: Two States, One Homeland (opens another site)A Land for All
- Joint press release on the July 2024 Palestinian-Israeli Pulse (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research and Tel Aviv University
Report an error or suggest a source on this page →
Change history
- Each point's summary is split in two, under "Within Israeli society" and "Within Palestinian society", after a shared line where one applies; the Israeli column's opening says plainly that more than a quarter of Israeli Jews do not know; the point on settlements is titled "Settlements and the West Bank", the site's own term; "ending occupation" is quoted as PCPSR's question wording, with its passage as a source.