Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 5 · Land and law since 1967 · question 1 of 3
Are Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, lawful under international law?
Last reviewed
Background · 6 key momentsHow settlement unfoldedNew to the subject? Start here.
12 August 1949
The Fourth Geneva Convention, on the protection of civilians in time of war, was adopted. [1]Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (Fourth Geneva Convention)(opens another site in a new tab)
June 1967
In the Six-Day War, Israel took control of the West Bank, including East Jerusalem. [2]Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory: Advisory Opinion, with separate opinions and declarations(opens another site in a new tab)
1979
After Israel’s Supreme Court ruled against a settlement built on private Palestinian land at Elon Moreh, the government decided that settlements would be established only on land it considers state land. [3]Summary of the Opinion Concerning Unauthorized Outposts (Sasson report)(opens another site in a new tab)[4]HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation(opens another site in a new tab)
September 1995
The Interim Agreement between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization left settlements to the permanent status negotiations. [5]Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip(opens another site in a new tab)
June 2020
By eight votes to one, Israel’s Supreme Court struck down a 2017 law that had retroactively legalised about 4,000 settler homes built on privately owned Palestinian land. [6]Constitutional Adjudication of International Law Violations(opens another site in a new tab)[7]Israel's Supreme Court strikes down law legalizing settlements on private Palestinian land(opens another site in a new tab)
End of 2024
By the European Union’s count, which includes Israeli neighbourhoods in East Jerusalem, about 737,000 Israeli settlers lived in the West Bank, about 234,000 of them in East Jerusalem. [8]Report on Israeli Settlements in the occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem (January–December 2024)(opens another site in a new tab)
In brief
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
Israel’s settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, are unlawful, because an occupying power is prohibited from transferring its own civilian population into territory it occupies.
The West Bank, including East Jerusalem, has been under Israeli military occupation since 1967, so the Fourth Geneva Convention applies there. Its Article 49 prohibits an occupying power from transferring parts of its own civilian population into occupied territory. The Security Council and the International Court of Justice have both found that the settlements breach that prohibition.
Where this is argued: [9]Identical letters dated 7 June 2012 from the Permanent Observer of Palestine to the United Nations addressed to the Secretary-General and the President of the Security Council(opens another site in a new tab)[10]Written Statement of the State of Palestine (advisory proceedings on the policies and practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory)(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
Israeli communities in Judea and Samaria are not unlawful, because the Fourth Geneva Convention’s prohibition does not reach voluntary settlement on land that had no lawful sovereign before 1967 and that the League of Nations Mandate opened to Jewish settlement.
When Israel took control of Judea and Samaria in 1967, the land was not the recognised sovereign territory of any state, so the Convention does not apply to it as a matter of law. The prohibition in Article 49 was written against forced population transfers and does not cover people who choose where to live. The agreements between Israel and the Palestinians leave the future of these communities to negotiation.
Where this is argued: [11]The Settlements Issue: Distorting the Geneva Convention and the Oslo Accords, by Alan Baker(opens another site in a new tab)[12]Israeli Settlements and International Law (excerpt)(opens another site in a new tab)[13]Remarks to the press by Secretary of State Michael R. Pompeo on United States policy towards Israeli settlements(opens another site in a new tab)
What it turns on: The two sides disagree on whether the Fourth Geneva Convention applies to this territory at all, and on whether its ban on an occupying power transferring its own population covers people who move there by choice. The international bodies that have addressed these questions agree: the International Court of Justice, in 2004 and in 2024, and the Security Council, in 2016, concluded that the settlements breach international law. Israel’s government disputes this, and Israel’s Supreme Court has not ruled on it.
A note on terms
Most states and United Nations bodies call this territory the West Bank, and the Security Council refers to “the Palestinian territory occupied since 1967, including East Jerusalem”. Israel’s government calls it Judea and Samaria. This page uses “West Bank” in its own voice and each side’s own term in that side’s column. [14]Security Council resolution 2334 (2016)(opens another site in a new tab)[12]Israeli Settlements and International Law (excerpt)(opens another site in a new tab)
The Security Council and the International Court of Justice describe the territory as occupied. Israel’s government holds that the land “did not belong to a previous lawful sovereign”, and on that basis disputes that the law of occupation applies to it as a matter of right. [14]Security Council resolution 2334 (2016)(opens another site in a new tab)[15]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968)(opens another site in a new tab)[12]Israeli Settlements and International Law (excerpt)(opens another site in a new tab)
Israel has applied its own law in East Jerusalem since 1967 and regards it as part of its capital. The Security Council and the International Court of Justice treat East Jerusalem as part of the occupied territory, and count Israeli neighbourhoods there as settlements. [15]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968)(opens another site in a new tab)[14]Security Council resolution 2334 (2016)(opens another site in a new tab)
A point about the French version of this page. In French, the United Nations and most states call these places « colonies ». Israel’s government regards that word as negatively loaded and associated with colonial empires, and prefers « implantations ». The French page uses « colonies » in its own voice, following international usage, and « implantations » in the column for Israel’s position. [16]Résolution 2334 (2016) du Conseil de sécurité (texte français)(opens another site in a new tab)[17]Lexique du conflit israélo-palestinien(opens another site in a new tab)
Point by point
Point 1 of 5
Does the Fourth Geneva Convention apply to this territory?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Interpretation
The Convention applies to any territory occupied in an armed conflict between states that are party to it, whatever that territory’s status was beforehand.
- Factual claim
In its advisory opinion of July 2024, the International Court of Justice concluded that the Fourth Geneva Convention is applicable in the Occupied Palestinian Territory.
[15]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Alfred Witkon
In the Elon Moreh case of 1979, Justice Witkon of Israel’s Supreme Court wrote that it is “a mistake to think” that the Geneva Convention does not apply to Judea and Samaria: “It does apply”, though it was not “justiciable” in that court.
[4]HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Article 2 of the Fourth Geneva Convention says the Convention applies to the occupation of “the territory of a High Contracting Party”.
[1]Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (Fourth Geneva Convention)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Jordan’s rule over Judea and Samaria between 1948 and 1967 was not generally recognised as sovereignty, so the land was not the territory of a party to the Convention, and the Convention does not apply to it as a matter of law.
- Position ·Israeli government
Israel’s government has taken the position that the Convention does not apply to this territory as a matter of law, but that it acts in accordance with the Convention’s humanitarian provisions. In the Elon Moreh case of 1979, the State argued before the Supreme Court that settlement on the land did not conflict with the humanitarian provisions of the Convention “that are acceptable to the State of Israel”.
[18]The West Bank and International Humanitarian Law on the Eve of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Six-Day War(opens another site in a new tab)[4]HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation(opens another site in a new tab)
Point 2 of 5
What does the sixth paragraph of Article 49 prohibit?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The sixth paragraph of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention reads: “The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.”
[1]Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (Fourth Geneva Convention)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The Court has stated that the sixth paragraph prohibits not only forced transfers but also “any measures taken by an occupying Power in order to organize or encourage transfers of parts of its own population into the occupied territory”.
[15]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
When a state plans, funds, and protects settlements, that is a transfer of its population, even where each settler moves by choice.
- Factual claim
In September 1967 the legal adviser to Israel’s Foreign Ministry, Theodor Meron, advised the government that establishing civilian settlements in the occupied territories would violate the Fourth Geneva Convention.
[18]The West Bank and International Humanitarian Law on the Eve of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Six-Day War(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In the Elon Moreh case of 1979, about land taken from its Palestinian owners for a settlement, Israel’s Supreme Court found that “the decisive consideration that motivated the government to decide upon the relevant settlement was not the military consideration”, and ordered the settlers removed from the land.
[4]HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
According to the International Committee of the Red Cross, Article 49 concerns situations where populations are coerced into being transferred.
[11]The Settlements Issue: Distorting the Geneva Convention and the Oslo Accords, by Alan Baker(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The sixth paragraph of Article 49 was written to prevent forced population transfers of the kind carried out in the Second World War. It does not cover individuals who move of their own free will.
- Position ·Alfred Witkon
In the Elon Moreh case of 1979, Justice Witkon of Israel’s Supreme Court wrote that the question whether voluntary settlement falls under the sixth paragraph “is not easy, and as far as we know, it has yet to be resolved in international case law”.
[4]HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation(opens another site in a new tab)
Point 3 of 5
Does the League of Nations Mandate give a right to settle there?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Interpretation
The Mandate was a temporary trust, meant to lead to the independence of the people of Palestine. It gives no continuing right to settle the land.
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Article 6 of the 1922 Mandate for Palestine required the administration to encourage “close settlement by Jews on the land, including State lands and waste lands not required for public purposes”.
[21]The Palestine Mandate(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The right of Jews to settle in this land, recognised in the Mandate, was preserved when the United Nations was founded and has never been lawfully ended.
Point 4 of 5
What does the 1995 Interim Agreement allow?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The 1995 Interim Agreement provides that neither side shall take any step that will change the status of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip pending the outcome of the permanent status negotiations.
[5]Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Building and expanding settlements changes the status of the territory, and so breaches the Interim Agreement as well as the Convention.
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
The 1995 Interim Agreement between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization lists settlements among the issues to be covered in permanent status negotiations.
[5]Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The agreements contain no provision that restricts building in these communities, so their future is a matter for negotiation between the parties and not of existing illegality.
Point 5 of 5
What have courts, the Security Council, and governments concluded?
The international bodies cited on this point, the Security Council and the International Court of Justice, reach the same conclusion; the positions cited on Israel’s side are a government’s, the United States’ statement of 2019, and that of Israel’s Supreme Court, which has left the question open.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
In resolution 2334 of December 2016, the Security Council reaffirmed that the establishment of settlements in the territory occupied since 1967, including East Jerusalem, “has no legal validity and constitutes a flagrant violation under international law”.
[14]Security Council resolution 2334 (2016)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In its advisory opinion of July 2024, the International Court of Justice considered that the transfer by Israel of settlers to the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and the maintenance of their presence, is contrary to the sixth paragraph of Article 49.
[15]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·US State Department
In April 1978 the Legal Adviser of the United States Department of State concluded that the establishment of civilian settlements in the territories occupied by Israel is inconsistent with international law.
[20]Letter of the State Department Legal Adviser concerning the legality of Israeli settlements in the occupied territories(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In its advisory opinion of July 2004 on the barrier, the International Court of Justice concluded that the settlements “have been established in breach of international law”.
[22]Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé : avis consultatif (document A/ES-10/273)(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory: Advisory Opinion, with separate opinions and declarations(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Thomas Buergenthal
Judge Thomas Buergenthal, who voted against the opinion, wrote that the sixth paragraph applies to the settlements and that their existence violates it.
[2]Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory: Advisory Opinion, with separate opinions and declarations(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Position ·Mike Pompeo
In November 2019 the United States Secretary of State said that the establishment of Israeli civilian settlements in the West Bank “is not per se inconsistent with international law”.
[13]Remarks to the press by Secretary of State Michael R. Pompeo on United States policy towards Israeli settlements(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Israel’s Supreme Court has not ruled on whether the settlements are lawful under international law. In 2020, when it struck down a law on settlement homes built on private Palestinian land, the majority opinion did not address the legitimacy of the settlements.
[23]The Advisory Opinion and the Jewish Settlements(opens another site in a new tab)[6]Constitutional Adjudication of International Law Violations(opens another site in a new tab)
Sources
- Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (Fourth Geneva Convention) (opens another site)United Nations
- Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory: Advisory Opinion, with separate opinions and declarations (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
- Summary of the Opinion Concerning Unauthorized Outposts (Sasson report) (opens another site)Talia Sasson, for the Prime Minister of Israel, published by the United Nations
- HCJ 390/79, Dweikat et al. v. Government of Israel (Elon Moreh), English translation (opens another site)Versa, Cardozo School of Law
- Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (opens another site)Uppsala Conflict Data Program (text of the agreement)
- Constitutional Adjudication of International Law Violations (opens another site)Verfassungsblog
- Israel's Supreme Court strikes down law legalizing settlements on private Palestinian land (opens another site)Reuters, published by NBC News
- Report on Israeli Settlements in the occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem (January–December 2024) (opens another site)European Union External Action Service
- Identical letters dated 7 June 2012 from the Permanent Observer of Palestine to the United Nations addressed to the Secretary-General and the President of the Security Council (opens another site)United Nations
- Written Statement of the State of Palestine (advisory proceedings on the policies and practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory) (opens another site)International Court of Justice
- The Settlements Issue: Distorting the Geneva Convention and the Oslo Accords, by Alan Baker (opens another site)Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs
- Israeli Settlements and International Law (excerpt) (opens another site)Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, as reproduced by Daily Alert
- Remarks to the press by Secretary of State Michael R. Pompeo on United States policy towards Israeli settlements (opens another site)United States Department of State, copy hosted by the United Nations
- Security Council resolution 2334 (2016) (opens another site)United Nations
- Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem: Advisory Opinion (UN document A/78/968) (opens another site)International Court of Justice, circulated by the United Nations
- Résolution 2334 (2016) du Conseil de sécurité (texte français) (opens another site)Nations Unies
- Lexique du conflit israélo-palestinien (opens another site)Diploweb, revue géopolitique
- The West Bank and International Humanitarian Law on the Eve of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Six-Day War (opens another site)Theodor Meron, American Journal of International Law
- Commentary of 1958 on Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention (opens another site)International Committee of the Red Cross
- Letter of the State Department Legal Adviser concerning the legality of Israeli settlements in the occupied territories (opens another site)United States Department of State, copy hosted by Just Security
- The Palestine Mandate (opens another site)League of Nations, text at the Avalon Project, Yale Law School
- Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé : avis consultatif (document A/ES-10/273) (opens another site)Cour internationale de Justice, publié par les Nations Unies
- The Advisory Opinion and the Jewish Settlements (opens another site)Israel Law Review, Cambridge University Press
Report an error or suggest a source on this page →
Change history
- “What it turns on” now says where the international bodies stand: the International Court of Justice (2004, 2024) and the Security Council (2016) concluded that the settlements breach international law; Israel’s government disputes this, and its Supreme Court has not ruled.
- The 1978 conclusion of the State Department’s legal adviser (b9) shown as the US State Department’s position.
- Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two.
- Added a note on the evidence under the point on what courts, the Security Council and governments have concluded.
- Added a background box (“How settlement unfolded”, 1949 to 2024) and new sourced statements on both sides: Israel’s position on the Convention, its Supreme Court’s rulings (Elon Moreh, 1979; the 2020 ruling on the Regularization Law), the Foreign Ministry legal adviser’s opinion of 1967, and the International Court of Justice’s 2004 opinion. One point retitled to include courts and governments.
- First published.