Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 5 · Land and law since 1967 · question 3 of 3
What shaped the Gaza Strip between 2005, when Israel removed its settlements and soldiers, and October 2023?
Last reviewed
Background · 7 key momentsHow the period unfoldedNew to the subject? Start here.
August 2005
Israel removed all 21 of its settlements in Gaza, about 8,500 settlers, and its soldiers, while keeping control of Gaza’s airspace, its sea and most of its land border. [1]Chronological Review of Events Relating to the Question of Palestine, August 2005(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Israel’s Disengagement from Gaza (RS22000)(opens another site in a new tab)[3]Israel’s Revised Disengagement Plan, 6 June 2004 (Prime Minister’s Office)(opens another site in a new tab)
November 2005
Israel and the Palestinian Authority signed an agreement on the crossings, including Rafah on the Egyptian border. [4]Agreement on Movement and Access and Agreed Principles for Rafah Crossing, 15 November 2005(opens another site in a new tab)
January 2006
Hamas won the Palestinian legislative election. The Quartet (the United States, the European Union, Russia and the UN) made its support conditional on recognising Israel, renouncing violence and accepting past agreements; Hamas refused, and sanctions followed. [5]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter II(opens another site in a new tab)[6]Quartet statement (“Quartet principles”), SG/2104(opens another site in a new tab)
June 2007
Hamas took control of Gaza by force from Fatah, in eight days of fighting. [7]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter IV(opens another site in a new tab)
September 2007
Israel declared Gaza “hostile territory”, citing rocket fire, and tightened restrictions on goods and fuel. [8]Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release)(opens another site in a new tab)
2008–2021
Four major rounds of fighting took place between Israel and armed groups in Gaza: December 2008 to January 2009, November 2012, summer 2014 and May 2021. [9]Occupied Palestinian Territory: Humanitarian Facts and Figures(opens another site in a new tab)[10]The Rebuilding of Gaza Amid Dire Conditions: Damage, Losses, and Needs (press release)(opens another site in a new tab)
2010
Israel eased the restrictions on food and consumer goods, while keeping a ban on goods it considers of dual civilian and military use. [11]Gisha, “Food Consumption in the Gaza Strip – Red Lines”: reader (reprinted by Jadaliyya)(opens another site in a new tab)[12]Intensified restrictions on entry of building materials delay completion of housing projects in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
In brief
Argued in support of Israel’s position
Israel left Gaza in 2005, soldiers and settlers alike; Hamas’s rise to power, its attacks and its choices in government brought the restrictions, the wars and the decline.
In 2005 Israel uprooted its own citizens and withdrew every soldier stationed inside Gaza, leaving Gazans the chance to build; donors even bought the settlers’ greenhouses for them, and dozens were looted within a month. Hamas then refused conditions the Palestinian Authority had accepted, seized Gaza by force in 2007, and fired thousands of rockets at Israeli towns, the crossings included. The restrictions were security measures against a hostile territory, and Egypt imposed its own; a UN panel found the naval blockade lawful. Hamas received up to $100 million a year from Iran from 2018 and built tunnels into Israel while silencing its critics, and the wars that followed its rocket fire cost Gaza dearly. Israel no longer controls what happens inside Gaza, as its High Court held, and is not its occupier.
Where this is argued: [8]Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release)(opens another site in a new tab)[13]Security Council, The situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question: verbatim record(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
Israel left Gaza in 2005 but kept its borders, sea and sky; the blockade it imposed and its repeated wars, above all, brought the decline.
Israel withdrew on its own terms and kept control of Gaza’s land perimeter, airspace, sea, crossings and supplies; the 2005 agreement that promised open crossings and a seaport was soon overtaken by closures. When Palestinians elected Hamas, they were punished with sanctions, and from 2007 Israel restricted food, building materials and almost all exports, which UN experts called collective punishment. Four wars killed thousands and destroyed homes that the restrictions then made slow to rebuild. The World Bank names the restrictions as the most important obstacle to Gaza’s economy, where income per head fell close to its lowest level since 1994. The International Court of Justice found that Israel kept key elements of authority over Gaza, and the ICRC considers it occupied still.
Where this is argued: [14]Identical letters dated 19 March 2010 from the Chargé d’affaires a.i. of the Permanent Observer Mission of Palestine to the United Nations(opens another site in a new tab)[15]UN experts call for lifting of Gaza blockade (press release)(opens another site in a new tab)
What it turns on: The sources on this page show that Israel removed its settlers and soldiers from Gaza in 2005 while keeping control of Gaza’s land perimeter, airspace and sea; that Hamas won the 2006 election and took sole control of Gaza by force in 2007; that Israel and Egypt then restricted the movement of people and goods; that armed groups fired thousands of rockets; and that Gaza’s economy fell far behind. The sides disagree on which of these caused the decline, on whether the restrictions were security measures or collective punishment, and on whether Israel still occupied Gaza. The International Court of Justice found in 2024 that Israel’s withdrawal did not entirely release it from its obligations under the law of occupation, and the International Committee of the Red Cross considers Gaza still occupied; Israel’s High Court held in 2008 that Israel no longer had effective control there.
A note on terms
Israel calls its 2005 withdrawal from Gaza the “disengagement”. It removed the settlements and the soldiers stationed inside Gaza; under the plan, Israel kept control of Gaza’s land perimeter, airspace and sea, and continued to supply its electricity, water and fuel. [3]Israel’s Revised Disengagement Plan, 6 June 2004 (Prime Minister’s Office)(opens another site in a new tab)
The restrictions on people and goods tightened from 2007 are called a “blockade” by the United Nations, “sanctions” or security restrictions by Israel’s government, and a “siege” by Palestinian officials. Egypt controls the Rafah crossing and restricted it too. On this page each side’s column uses its own term, and the site says “the restrictions”. [12]Intensified restrictions on entry of building materials delay completion of housing projects in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)[8]Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release)(opens another site in a new tab)[16]Letter from the Permanent Observer of the State of Palestine to the United Nations, 2016(opens another site in a new tab)
Point by point
Point 1 of 8
What did Israel’s withdrawal change, and what control did it keep?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
In August 2005 Israel removed all 21 settlements in the Gaza Strip, with some 8,500 to 9,000 settlers, and four in the northern West Bank. Its army and police carried out the evacuation, under a law that compensated the settlers and against continued opposition from a militant minority in Israel.
[1]Chronological Review of Events Relating to the Question of Palestine, August 2005(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Israel’s Disengagement from Gaza (RS22000)(opens another site in a new tab)[17]Office of the Special Envoy for Disengagement, Periodic Report, September 2005(opens another site in a new tab)[18]Briefing by the Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs to the Security Council, as recorded in the UN’s review of 2005(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The Quartet’s Special Envoy reported in September 2005 that, apart from the settlers’ houses, which were dismantled by agreement, the settlement assets “were in large part left intact for the benefit of the Palestinians”. American Jewish donors bought more than 3,000 of the settlers’ greenhouses and handed them to the Palestinian Authority.
[17]Office of the Special Envoy for Disengagement, Periodic Report, September 2005(opens another site in a new tab)[19]Palestinians in Gaza Loot Greenhouse Equipment (Associated Press)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Within a month, looters took irrigation hoses, pumps and plastic sheeting from dozens of the greenhouses; in some instances, witnesses said, police joined them, and the Palestinian deputy finance minister said about 30 per cent were damaged. In early February 2006, after the guards left their posts because they had not been paid, further looting put about 70 acres out of action.
[19]Palestinians in Gaza Loot Greenhouse Equipment (Associated Press)(opens another site in a new tab)[20]Looters steal Gaza greenhouses (Reuters)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Israel withdrew from inside Gaza, at a real cost to its own citizens, and left behind what Gazans needed to start building. It kept control of its own borders, as any state does facing a hostile territory; what Gaza became inside those borders was decided by those who ruled it.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
Israel’s plan, adopted after it concluded that there was “no reliable Palestinian partner”, provided that after the withdrawal Israel would “guard and monitor the external land perimeter of the Gaza Strip, will continue to maintain exclusive authority in Gaza air space, and will continue to exercise security activity in the sea”, and would continue to supply Gaza’s electricity, water and fuel.
[3]Israel’s Revised Disengagement Plan, 6 June 2004 (Prime Minister’s Office)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The Agreement on Movement and Access of November 2005 provided that the crossings “will operate continuously”, that Israel would allow convoys between Gaza and the West Bank, and that construction of a seaport could begin. A year later the UN found that Gazans’ access to the West Bank or the outside world “remains extremely limited and the flow of commercial trade is negligible”.
[4]Agreement on Movement and Access and Agreed Principles for Rafah Crossing, 15 November 2005(opens another site in a new tab)[21]Agreement on Movement and Access: One-year review(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The greenhouse project lost $2 million worth of crops that could not be exported to Europe because Israel closed the commercial crossing; Israeli security sources said it was closed because of intelligence that attacks were planned there.
[20]Looters steal Gaza greenhouses (Reuters)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The withdrawal was decided by Israel alone, without agreement with the Palestinians, and it kept the keys: the borders, the sea, the sky, the crossings and the supplies. Control moved from inside Gaza to its edges. It did not end.
Point 2 of 8
How did Hamas come to rule Gaza, and how did others respond?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Before Hamas formed a government, the Quartet set three conditions for dealing with it: commitment to non-violence, recognition of Israel, and acceptance of previous agreements. Israel told the UN Security Council it would negotiate only once they were met. President Abbas had affirmed the Palestinian Authority’s commitment to previous agreements; Hamas refused the conditions.
[6]Quartet statement (“Quartet principles”), SG/2104(opens another site in a new tab)[13]Security Council, The situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question: verbatim record(opens another site in a new tab)[5]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter II(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In June 2007 Hamas took control of Gaza by force. Human Rights Watch found that “In eight days Hamas forces seized control of all security facilities and main government offices throughout the territory”, and that both Fatah and Hamas forces committed serious violations, including summary executions and torture.
[7]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter IV(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Hamas refused conditions that the Palestinian Authority itself had accepted, and then seized Gaza by force. The restrictions that followed were the response to an armed group that refused to recognise Israel taking over the territory next door.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
Hamas won 74 of the 132 seats in the Palestinian Legislative Council in January 2006. When it formed a government, Israel and the Quartet responded by imposing sanctions.
[5]Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter II(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Palestinians were punished for how they voted. Cutting off the elected government deepened the split between Hamas and Fatah that ended in the fighting of 2007, in which both sides committed abuses.
Point 3 of 8
What did the restrictions cover, and why were they imposed?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
On 19 September 2007 Israel’s Security Cabinet, meeting “in light of both the continued Kassam rocket fire from the Gaza Strip at Sderot and other communities near the Gaza Strip”, declared that “Hamas is a terrorist organization that has taken control of the Gaza Strip and turned it into hostile territory”. It decided to restrict goods, fuel and electricity, “while taking into account both the humanitarian aspects relevant to the Gaza Strip and the intention to avoid a humanitarian crisis”.
[8]Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·UN panel of inquiry
A UN panel of inquiry found in 2011 that “The naval blockade was imposed as a legitimate security measure in order to prevent weapons from entering Gaza by sea and its implementation complied with the requirements of international law”, while finding Israel’s boarding of the 2010 flotilla excessive and unreasonable.
[22]Report of the Secretary-General’s Panel of Inquiry on the 31 May 2010 Gaza Flotilla Incident (Palmer report), summary(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Eitan Dangot
The head of Israel’s coordination unit for the territories testified that goods into Gaza were restricted also because of rocket fire at Israel, “particularly at the crossings”.
[11]Gisha, “Food Consumption in the Gaza Strip – Red Lines”: reader (reprinted by Jadaliyya)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Egypt also restricted Gaza: between July 2013 and August 2015 it demolished at least 3,255 buildings along its border with the Strip, which Egypt justified as a way of shutting down the smuggling tunnels.
[23]“Look for Another Homeland”: Forced Evictions in Egypt’s Rafah(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The restrictions were security measures against an enemy that fired at Israel’s towns and at the very crossings goods passed through. Egypt, an Arab state, restricted Gaza too, citing the tunnels. A territory that sends rockets cannot expect open borders.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
Israel’s Security Cabinet decided in September 2007 to restrict goods, fuel and electricity to Gaza. A policy restricting the entry of food was in effect from 2007 to 2010; from July 2007 to June 2008 an average of ninety trucks entered each working day. From 2010 the restrictions mainly covered goods Israel considered to have military as well as civilian use, a list that included cement, gravel and steel bars.
[8]Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release)(opens another site in a new tab)[11]Gisha, “Food Consumption in the Gaza Strip – Red Lines”: reader (reprinted by Jadaliyya)(opens another site in a new tab)[12]Intensified restrictions on entry of building materials delay completion of housing projects in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The UN Country Team reported in 2012 that “Exports have nearly been brought to a halt due to restrictions.”
[24]Gaza in 2020: A liveable place? (United Nations Country Team)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·UN independent experts
UN independent experts said in 2011 that the 1.6 million people of Gaza were “subjected to collective punishment, in flagrant contravention of international human rights and humanitarian law”.
[15]UN experts call for lifting of Gaza blockade (press release)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Palestinian UN mission
Palestine’s UN mission called it collective punishment “on the scale of a war crime”.
[14]Identical letters dated 19 March 2010 from the Chargé d’affaires a.i. of the Permanent Observer Mission of Palestine to the United Nations(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·UN Human Rights Council mission
A UN Human Rights Council fact-finding mission found in 2010 that the blockade was “inflicting disproportionate damage upon the civilian population” and that intercepting the flotilla was illegal.
[25]Report of the international fact-finding mission to investigate violations of international law resulting from the Israeli attacks on the flotilla of ships carrying humanitarian assistance (A/HRC/15/21)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Restricting food for three years, and building materials and exports for far longer, punished two million people for the acts of armed groups. Security does not require halting a territory’s exports.
Point 4 of 8
What did rocket fire, tunnels and the wars cost Gaza?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
A UN fact-finding mission reported in 2009 that Palestinian armed groups had launched “about 8000 rockets and mortars into southern Israel since 2001”. In the summer of 2014 alone, the UN counted 4,881 rockets and 1,753 mortars fired towards Israel. In March 2014 Israel found a concrete-lined tunnel reaching almost half a mile into Israel, and Hamas “acknowledged ownership and military intent”.
[26]Report of the United Nations Fact-Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict (A/HRC/12/48)(opens another site in a new tab)[27]Report of the detailed findings of the independent commission of inquiry established pursuant to Human Rights Council resolution S-21/1 (A/HRC/29/CRP.4)(opens another site in a new tab)[28]The Tunnels Under Gaza(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Israel fought in Gaza to stop the fire on its towns. The cost of those wars to Gazans is the cost of Hamas’s decision to wage war from among them, and to build tunnels into Israel rather than homes.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The UN counted over 3,800 Palestinians and 90 Israelis killed in the escalations of 2008–09, 2012 and 2014. In 2014 alone over 18,000 homes in Gaza were destroyed or severely damaged, displacing 100,000 people. The eleven days of fighting in May 2021 killed 256 people in Gaza and caused up to $380 million in physical damage.
[9]Occupied Palestinian Territory: Humanitarian Facts and Figures(opens another site in a new tab)[10]The Rebuilding of Gaza Amid Dire Conditions: Damage, Losses, and Needs (press release)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Each war destroyed homes and infrastructure, and the restrictions on cement and steel slowed their rebuilding. No economy can grow under that cycle.
Point 5 of 8
How did Hamas govern and spend?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
The US Treasury reported in 2024 that Iran had provided “as much as $100 million per year to Hamas since 2018”. Human Rights Watch reported in 2018 that the Palestinian Authority and Hamas both used detention “to punish critics and deter them and others from further activism”.
[29]FinCEN Advisory on Iran-backed terrorist organizations(opens another site in a new tab)[30]Two Authorities, One Way, Zero Dissent: Arbitrary Arrest and Torture Under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Hamas had money for rockets and tunnels while Gaza lacked power and clean water. A government that silences its critics and spends on war shows where its priorities lie.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Interpretation
Hamas’s abuses are real, and Palestinians suffer from them. But misrule does not explain why Gaza could not export, travel or rebuild: those were decided at crossings Israel controlled.
Point 6 of 8
Why did Israel allow Qatari money into Gaza?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Israel’s security cabinet approved the Qatari payments in August 2018. Under the plan, Israel’s domestic security service, the Shin Bet, would monitor the list of recipients to try to ensure that members of Hamas’s military wing did not benefit directly.
[31]Gaza: Suitcases of $15M in cash from Qatar bring relief(opens another site in a new tab)[32]Qatar sent millions to Gaza for years – with Israel’s backing. Here’s what we know about the controversial deal(opens another site in a new tab)[33]“Buying Quiet”: Inside the Israeli plan that propped up Hamas (The New York Times, 10 December 2023), printed in the Congressional Record, 14 March 2024(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Benjamin Netanyahu
In 2018 Netanyahu said the arrangement was made “in coordination with security experts to return calm to (Israeli) villages of the south, but also to prevent a humanitarian disaster (in Gaza)”. In 2024 he said successive governments agreed to it because “we wanted to make sure that Gaza has a functioning civilian administration to avoid humanitarian collapse.”
[32]Qatar sent millions to Gaza for years – with Israel’s backing. Here’s what we know about the controversial deal(opens another site in a new tab)[34]Read the Full Transcript of Benjamin Netanyahu’s Interview With TIME(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Yossi Cohen
In December 2020 the head of the Mossad, Yossi Cohen, wrote to Qatar thanking it for its aid to Gaza: “these humanitarian efforts have played a crucial role in improving the humanitarian situation within the Gaza Strip, and ensuring stability and safety in the region.”
[35]Documents reveal Netanyahu government asked Qatar to keep funding Gaza(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Netanyahu’s office
In December 2023 an official in Netanyahu’s office said in a statement that Israeli governments had enabled money to go to Gaza for humanitarian reasons, not to strengthen Hamas, and that “Prime Minister Netanyahu acted to weaken Hamas significantly.”
[33]“Buying Quiet”: Inside the Israeli plan that propped up Hamas (The New York Times, 10 December 2023), printed in the Congressional Record, 14 March 2024(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Lahav Harkov
The journalist who first reported Netanyahu’s remark of 2019, Lahav Harkov, wrote in 2023 that the policy “was one that a long series of top security officials and even Netanyahu’s rivals upheld”. Benny Gantz and Naftali Bennett, who had attacked the payments, “did not stop the flow of funds once they had the power to make a change”; Netanyahu, she added, “carries the ultimate responsibility”.
[36]I reported on Netanyahu green-lighting Gaza aid - but there's more to the story(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The payments were a choice made by successive governments and the security services to keep Gaza from collapse and its border quiet. That the policy failed on 7 October shows a misreading of Hamas, not a plan to strengthen it.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Position ·Lahav Harkov
In March 2019 The Jerusalem Post reported, from a member of the Knesset’s paraphrase that another person in the room confirmed, that Netanyahu told his party’s lawmakers that “Whoever is against a Palestinian state should be for” allowing the money into Gaza, and that driving a wedge between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas helps prevent a Palestinian state. The reporter, Lahav Harkov, gave this account of her sources in 2023.
[37]Netanyahu: Money to Hamas part of strategy to keep Palestinians divided(opens another site in a new tab)[36]I reported on Netanyahu green-lighting Gaza aid - but there's more to the story(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Haaretz reported in February 2019 that Qatar had provided Hamas in the Gaza Strip with over $1.1 billion from 2012 to 2018, “with the approval of the Israeli government”.
[38]With Israel’s Consent, Qatar Gave Gaza $1 Billion Since 2012(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Qatar spent about $30 million a month in Gaza to run its only power plant and to support needy families and Hamas-hired public servants. After the fighting of May 2021, Israel and the United States demanded changes to the payments; Hamas endorsed a mechanism involving the Palestinian Authority and the UN, which Israeli officials saw as a safeguard against Hamas diverting the money to military needs.
[39]Qatar to resume payments to Gaza (Reuters)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·The New York Times
A New York Times investigation of December 2023 concluded that Netanyahu “gambled that a strong Hamas (but not too strong) would keep the peace and reduce pressure for a Palestinian state”.
[33]“Buying Quiet”: Inside the Israeli plan that propped up Hamas (The New York Times, 10 December 2023), printed in the Congressional Record, 14 March 2024(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Palestinian Authority
When the first cash arrived in November 2018, the Palestinian Authority’s official news agency published a statement accusing Hamas of “selling Palestinian blood for $15 million” and of acting “in accord with the Zionist-American conspiracy aimed at separating the West Bank from the Gaza Strip”.
[40]Qatar delivers $15 million to Gaza to help pay civil servants and cool unrest(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Mahmoud Abbas
Mahmoud Abbas said in December 2018: “Netanyahu personally takes money and gives it to Hamas”, which, he said, was turning it into weapons in the West Bank.
[41]Abbas attacks Netanyahu for letting Qatari funds into Gaza(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Keeping Hamas in power in Gaza kept the Palestinians under two rival governments, and a divided people could be said to have no partner for a state. The money bought quiet at the expense of the Palestinian Authority, which opposed it.
Point 7 of 8
What happened to Gaza’s economy, and what caused it?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Gaza’s decline began before the restrictions of 2007. OCHA reported that unemployment in Gaza rose from 33.1 per cent to 41.8 per cent between 2005 and 2006, the year after the withdrawal, though it said the increased closure of the crossings had contributed. The World Bank put Gaza’s compounded annual growth rate since 1994 at “only 1 percent”.
[21]Agreement on Movement and Access: One-year review(opens another site in a new tab)[42]Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, November 2021(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Gaza fell behind the West Bank because of who ruled it: Hamas’s takeover, its wars and its split from the Palestinian Authority left Gaza isolated, and gave Israel and Egypt their reasons to keep the crossings closed.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The World Bank estimated in 2016 that “GDP losses in Gaza, since the blockade of 2007, are above 50 percent”, and in 2021 that “the external restrictions on Gaza resulted in a closed economy”. In 2022 unemployment was 45.3 per cent in Gaza against 13.1 per cent in the West Bank, which the World Bank attributed to Israel’s movement restrictions creating a “near-blockade”.
[43]Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, September 2016(opens another site in a new tab)[42]Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, November 2021(opens another site in a new tab)[44]Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, May 2023(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
UNCTAD found that in 2022, despite growth that year, Gaza’s GDP per head was “close to the lowest level since 1994”. OCHA reported in 2022 that 62 per cent of Gazans needed food assistance, that power cuts averaged 11 hours a day in 2021, and that 78 per cent of piped water was unfit to drink.
[45]Report on UNCTAD assistance to the Palestinian people (TD/B/EX(74)/2)(opens another site in a new tab)[46]Gaza Strip: The humanitarian impact of 15 years of the blockade, June 2022(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The decline was above all the result of a policy decided at the crossings. Hamas’s misrule made things worse; it did not close Gaza’s borders.
Point 8 of 8
Did Gaza remain occupied after 2005?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Israel’s plan stated that its completion “will serve to dispel the claims regarding Israel's responsibility for the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip”. In 2008 Israel’s High Court of Justice held that “since September 2005 Israel no longer has effective control over what takes place within the territory of the Gaza Strip”.
[3]Israel’s Revised Disengagement Plan, 6 June 2004 (Prime Minister’s Office)(opens another site in a new tab)[47]Joint written statement by Al-Haq, Defence for Children International and others to the Human Rights Council, quoting Israel’s High Court of Justice in HCJ 9132/07 (A/HRC/7/NGO)(opens another site in a new tab)[48]The Implications of Bassiouni v. Prime Minister for Humanitarian Assistance in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Occupation means governing a territory on the ground. Israel keeps no officials, no administration and no stationed forces in Gaza; guarding its own borders, airspace and coast against a hostile territory is not occupying it. Egypt controls Gaza’s other border too.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The International Court of Justice found in 2024 that Israel kept “certain key elements of authority over the Gaza Strip, including control of the land, sea and air borders, restrictions on movement of people and goods, collection of import and export taxes, and military control over the buffer zone”, and that its withdrawal “has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation”.
[49]Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, Advisory Opinion(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·ICRC
The International Committee of the Red Cross “considers Gaza to remain occupied territory”.
[50]IHL and the occupied Palestinian territories: occupying power responsibilities(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
A power that controls a territory’s borders, sea, sky, trade and taxes controls the territory, whether or not its soldiers are stationed inside. Gaza remained occupied.
Sources
- Chronological Review of Events Relating to the Question of Palestine, August 2005 (opens another site)United Nations, Division for Palestinian Rights
- Israel’s Disengagement from Gaza (RS22000) (opens another site)US Congressional Research Service (via EveryCRSReport)
- Israel’s Revised Disengagement Plan, 6 June 2004 (Prime Minister’s Office) (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Agreement on Movement and Access and Agreed Principles for Rafah Crossing, 15 November 2005 (opens another site)United Nations Peacemaker
- Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter II (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Quartet statement (“Quartet principles”), SG/2104 (opens another site)United Nations
- Internal Fight: Palestinian Abuses in Gaza and the West Bank, chapter IV (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Security Cabinet declares Gaza hostile territory (Israeli Foreign Ministry press release) (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Occupied Palestinian Territory: Humanitarian Facts and Figures (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
- The Rebuilding of Gaza Amid Dire Conditions: Damage, Losses, and Needs (press release) (opens another site)World Bank
- Gisha, “Food Consumption in the Gaza Strip – Red Lines”: reader (reprinted by Jadaliyya) (opens another site)Jadaliyya
- Intensified restrictions on entry of building materials delay completion of housing projects in Gaza (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
- Security Council, The situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question: verbatim record (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Identical letters dated 19 March 2010 from the Chargé d’affaires a.i. of the Permanent Observer Mission of Palestine to the United Nations (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- UN experts call for lifting of Gaza blockade (press release) (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Letter from the Permanent Observer of the State of Palestine to the United Nations, 2016 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Office of the Special Envoy for Disengagement, Periodic Report, September 2005 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Briefing by the Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs to the Security Council, as recorded in the UN’s review of 2005 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Palestinians in Gaza Loot Greenhouse Equipment (Associated Press) (opens another site)Los Angeles Times
- Looters steal Gaza greenhouses (Reuters) (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- Agreement on Movement and Access: One-year review (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), via UNISPAL
- Report of the Secretary-General’s Panel of Inquiry on the 31 May 2010 Gaza Flotilla Incident (Palmer report), summary (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- “Look for Another Homeland”: Forced Evictions in Egypt’s Rafah (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Gaza in 2020: A liveable place? (United Nations Country Team) (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Report of the international fact-finding mission to investigate violations of international law resulting from the Israeli attacks on the flotilla of ships carrying humanitarian assistance (A/HRC/15/21) (opens another site)UN Human Rights Council
- Report of the United Nations Fact-Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict (A/HRC/12/48) (opens another site)UN Human Rights Council
- Report of the detailed findings of the independent commission of inquiry established pursuant to Human Rights Council resolution S-21/1 (A/HRC/29/CRP.4) (opens another site)UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (via UNISPAL)
- The Tunnels Under Gaza (opens another site)TIME
- FinCEN Advisory on Iran-backed terrorist organizations (opens another site)US Department of the Treasury, Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
- Two Authorities, One Way, Zero Dissent: Arbitrary Arrest and Torture Under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Gaza: Suitcases of $15M in cash from Qatar bring relief (opens another site)CNN
- Qatar sent millions to Gaza for years – with Israel’s backing. Here’s what we know about the controversial deal (opens another site)CNN
- “Buying Quiet”: Inside the Israeli plan that propped up Hamas (The New York Times, 10 December 2023), printed in the Congressional Record, 14 March 2024 (opens another site)The New York Times, as printed in the Congressional Record
- Read the Full Transcript of Benjamin Netanyahu’s Interview With TIME (opens another site)TIME
- Documents reveal Netanyahu government asked Qatar to keep funding Gaza (opens another site)Israel Hayom
- I reported on Netanyahu green-lighting Gaza aid - but there's more to the story (opens another site)Lahav Harkov’s newsletter (Substack)
- Netanyahu: Money to Hamas part of strategy to keep Palestinians divided (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
- With Israel’s Consent, Qatar Gave Gaza $1 Billion Since 2012 (opens another site)Haaretz
- Qatar to resume payments to Gaza (Reuters) (opens another site)Euronews
- Qatar delivers $15 million to Gaza to help pay civil servants and cool unrest (opens another site)Los Angeles Times
- Abbas attacks Netanyahu for letting Qatari funds into Gaza (opens another site)Al-Monitor
- Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, November 2021 (opens another site)World Bank
- Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, September 2016 (opens another site)World Bank
- Economic Monitoring Report to the Ad Hoc Liaison Committee, May 2023 (opens another site)World Bank
- Report on UNCTAD assistance to the Palestinian people (TD/B/EX(74)/2) (opens another site)UNCTAD (via UNISPAL)
- Gaza Strip: The humanitarian impact of 15 years of the blockade, June 2022 (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
- Joint written statement by Al-Haq, Defence for Children International and others to the Human Rights Council, quoting Israel’s High Court of Justice in HCJ 9132/07 (A/HRC/7/NGO) (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- The Implications of Bassiouni v. Prime Minister for Humanitarian Assistance in Gaza (opens another site)Harvard Humanitarian Initiative
- Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, Advisory Opinion (opens another site)International Court of Justice (via UNISPAL)
- IHL and the occupied Palestinian territories: occupying power responsibilities (opens another site)International Committee of the Red Cross
Report an error or suggest a source on this page →
Change history
- The page’s summary now says where the International Court of Justice, the Red Cross and Israel’s High Court stand on whether Gaza remained occupied after 2005.
- After review: the remark reported in 2019 (b23) now says first that it came from a lawmaker’s paraphrase, confirmed by another person present; the sources for the approval of 2018 (a21) and for Abbas’s words (b27) now quote the passages in full.
- New point: why Israel allowed Qatari money into Gaza, with the security cabinet’s approval of 2018, Netanyahu’s and his office’s reasons, the Mossad chief’s letter of thanks, the reported remark of 2019 and the journalist’s account of it, Haaretz’s figure, the New York Times investigation, and the Palestinian Authority’s and Abbas’s objections. The statement on Qatar’s payments moves into it.
- The testimony of COGAT’s head, Eitan Dangot, shown as his position; Egypt’s demolitions along the border are now a statement of their own (a10, a20).
- Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two.
- Added a background box with the main dates, from Israel’s removal of its settlements and soldiers in 2005 to the fighting of May 2021.
- The question no longer uses one side’s word, “withdrawal”, for 2005; it now says Israel removed its settlements and soldiers.
- The question no longer names the two causes; the page sets them out.
- First published.