Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 3 · Statehood and recognition · question 1 of 2

Have the Palestinians accepted Israel’s existence, and in what terms?

Last reviewed

Background · 7 key momentsThe main textsNew to the subject? Start here.
  1. July 1968

    The PLO’s revised charter called the partition of Palestine in 1947 and the establishment of Israel “entirely illegal”, and armed struggle “the only way to liberate Palestine”. [1]The Palestinian National Charter: Resolutions of the Palestine National Council, July 1-17, 1968, Article 19(opens another site in a new tab)

  2. August 1988

    Hamas’s founding charter said there was no solution to the Palestinian question except through jihad. [2]The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, 18 August 1988, Article 13(opens another site in a new tab)

  3. November 1988

    The PLO’s declaration of independence said that the 1947 resolution dividing Palestine into an Arab state and a Jewish state still provided the legal basis for Palestinian sovereignty and independence. [3]Palestinian Declaration of Independence, Algiers, 15 November 1988(opens another site in a new tab)

  4. September 1993

    In letters exchanged before the Oslo agreement, the PLO recognised “the right of the State of Israel to exist in peace and security”, and Israel recognised the PLO as the representative of the Palestinian people. [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)

  5. 1996 and 1998

    The Palestine National Council voted to cancel the charter’s articles contrary to the 1993 letters. In 1998, in front of the US president, Palestinian delegates confirmed it by a show of hands. [5]1996 amendments to the PLO Charter(opens another site in a new tab)[6]Clinton watches as Palestinians vote to annul anti-Israel clauses(opens another site in a new tab)

  6. May 2017

    Hamas published a new document that accepted a Palestinian state on the lines of 4 June 1967 as a formula of national consensus, while refusing to recognise Israel’s legitimacy. [7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)

  7. 2018

    The PLO’s Central Council voted to suspend recognition of Israel until Israel recognised a Palestinian state on the 1967 borders, and left it to the leadership to decide when to act on it. [8]PLO Central Council statement, 15 January 2018(opens another site in a new tab)[9]PLO votes to suspend recognition of Israel until it recognizes Palestinian state(opens another site in a new tab)

In brief

Argued in support of Israel’s position

The Palestinian side has not accepted Israel’s right to exist: the PLO’s recognition was partial and has been put in question, it refuses to accept Israel as the state of the Jewish people, and Hamas rejects Israel outright.

The PLO’s founding Charter called Israel’s creation illegal, and no amended Charter has ever been published. Its 1993 recognition came in a letter, and its own Central Council voted in 2018 to suspend it. Its leaders refuse to recognise Israel as a Jewish state. Hamas, which won the 2006 Palestinian elections and went on to control Gaza, says there will be no recognition at all. Polls show no majority for a state beside Israel, and schoolbook maps leave Israel out.

Where this is argued: [10]Speech by Prime Minister Netanyahu at the United Nations General Assembly, 23 September 2011(opens another site in a new tab)[11]Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

The Palestinians’ recognised representative, the PLO, accepted Israel’s right to exist in 1993 and has sought a state beside it ever since; the claim that “the Palestinians” refuse Israel’s existence treats Hamas as if it spoke for everyone and treats a refusal of the words “Jewish state” as a refusal of the state.

In 1988 the PLO based its claim to a state on the partition of Palestine into an Arab and a Jewish state. In 1993 it recognised, in writing, Israel’s right to exist in peace and security; Israel in return recognised the PLO, not a Palestinian state. The PLO’s council voted by more than two-thirds in 1996 to cancel the Charter articles that said otherwise. The words “Jewish state” are not in those letters. Hamas is not the PLO, and even it moved in 2017. When asked about a state on the 1967 lines, most Palestinians say yes.

Where this is argued: [11]Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state(opens another site in a new tab)[12]‘From the river to the sea’: One slogan, many meanings, by Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino(opens another site in a new tab)

What it turns on: Both sides agree on most of the documents: the PLO recognised Israel’s right to exist in 1993, it has refused to recognise Israel “as a Jewish state”, and Hamas refuses any recognition. They disagree on which of these speaks for “the Palestinians”, and on whether recognising a state without accepting how it defines itself is acceptance or a way of withholding it.

A note on terms

“The Palestinians” covers very different actors. The Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) is the body that Israel and most states recognise as the Palestinians’ representative; the Palestinian Authority, which it set up, administers parts of the West Bank. Hamas is a separate Islamist movement, outside the PLO, which governed Gaza from 2007. Public opinion is a third thing again. Each statement on this page says which is meant. [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)[7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)

Three things are often run together: recognising that Israel exists as a state; recognising its “right to exist”, the wording of the 1993 letter; and recognising it “as a Jewish state”, a wording Israel’s government asks for. A statement true of one is not thereby true of the others. [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)[11]Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state(opens another site in a new tab)

“A right to exist.” The phrase is older than the conflict. A 1916 declaration of the American Institute of International Law begins: “Every nation has the right to exist”. In 1949 the UN’s International Law Commission left such an article out of its draft declaration on the rights of states, finding it “tautological to say that an existing State has the right to exist”. International lawyers still disagree on whether it is a right of its own or another name for sovereignty and territorial integrity. It was used about Israel by the early 1950s. As a condition set for the PLO, it appears in a US–Israeli agreement of 1 September 1975: the United States would not recognise or negotiate with the PLO so long as it “does not recognize Israel’s right to exist”. In 1977 Prime Minister Begin told the Knesset that Israel would not ask anyone to recognise its right to exist, and in 1981 Abba Eban, a former foreign minister, wrote that “Nobody does Israel any service by proclaiming its ‘right to exist.’” The condition held all the same: in December 1988 the United States opened talks with the PLO once it had “recognized Israel’s right to exist”, the White House adding that “These have long been our conditions”; the PLO used the phrase itself in its 1993 letter; and in 2011 President Obama said that “any Palestinian partner must recognize Israel’s right to exist”. [13]Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Nations, American Institute of International Law, 6 January 1916, in Documents of the United Nations Conference on International Organization, vol. III(opens another site in a new tab)[14]Draft Declaration on Rights and Duties of States, with commentaries(opens another site in a new tab)[15]Statement on Diplomatic Talks With the Palestine Liberation Organization, 14 December 1988(opens another site in a new tab)[16]Addresses by President Barack Obama on the Middle East(opens another site in a new tab)[17]An Expert Opinion on the Question of Israel’s Right to Exist(opens another site in a new tab)[18]Jure Vidmar, The Concept of the State and its Right of Existence, Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law 4(3)(opens another site in a new tab)[19]Israel Lauded in U.S. Congress; Greeted on Its Fourth Anniversary(opens another site in a new tab)[20]Memorandum of Agreement between the Governments of Israel and the United States, 1 September 1975 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, vol. XXVI, doc. 227)(opens another site in a new tab)[21]Statement to the Knesset by Prime Minister Begin upon the presentation of his government, 20 June 1977(opens another site in a new tab)[22]Abba Eban on Israel’s “Right to Exist” (from The New York Times, 18 November 1981)(opens another site in a new tab)[4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)

Point by point

Point 1 of 8

Has the PLO recognised Israel?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·PLO

    The PLO’s National Charter of 1968 says that “the establishment of the state of Israel” is “entirely illegal, regardless of the passage of time”, and that armed struggle is “the only way to liberate Palestine”.

    [1]The Palestinian National Charter: Resolutions of the Palestine National Council, July 1-17, 1968, Article 19(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In January 2018 the PLO’s Central Council instructed the organisation’s Executive Committee to suspend recognition of Israel until Israel recognises a State of Palestine on the 1967 lines. It repeated the decision in October 2018.

    [8]PLO Central Council statement, 15 January 2018(opens another site in a new tab)[9]PLO votes to suspend recognition of Israel until it recognizes Palestinian state(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    The recognition of 1993 was a letter from one leader, given in exchange for something, and the PLO’s own bodies have since voted to suspend it. A recognition that can be put to a vote and withdrawn is a bargaining position, not an acceptance that Israel is there by right.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Position ·Palestine National Council

    The Palestinian declaration of independence of 1988 rests its claim to statehood on the United Nations resolution of 1947 that, in its words, “partitioned Palestine into two states, Arab and Jewish”.

    [3]Palestinian Declaration of Independence, Algiers, 15 November 1988(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    On 9 September 1993 the PLO’s chairman, Yasser Arafat, wrote to Israel’s Prime Minister: “The PLO recognizes the right of the State of Israel to exist in peace and security.” The letter declared the Charter’s provisions inconsistent with that commitment “inoperative and no longer valid”.

    [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Factual claim

    In reply, Israel recognised the PLO “as the representative of the Palestinian people”. Its letter did not recognise a Palestinian state or a Palestinian right to one.

    [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Factual claim

    The Central Council’s 2018 decisions left it to President Abbas and the PLO’s Executive Committee to decide whether and when to carry them out.

    [9]PLO votes to suspend recognition of Israel until it recognizes Palestinian state(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    The body that Israel itself accepted as the Palestinians’ representative recognised Israel’s right to exist, in writing, thirty years ago, and got no state in return. The 2018 votes asked only for the same recognition from the other side. To say “the Palestinians” refuse Israel’s existence erases that record.

Point 2 of 8

Was the recognition meant to last?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The political programme that the Palestine National Council adopted in June 1974 resolved to “employ all means, and first and foremost armed struggle, to liberate Palestinian territory and to establish the independent combatant national authority for the people over every part of Palestinian territory that is liberated”. It also resolved to “struggle against any proposal for a Palestinian entity the price of which is recognition, peace, secure frontiers”.

    [23]Political Programme of 9 June 1974, 12th Palestine National Council(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In a speech at a mosque in Johannesburg in May 1994, during his visit for Nelson Mandela’s inauguration, Arafat called for a “jihad” over Jerusalem. He “compared the PLO’s agreement with Israel to the 10-year peace pact that the Prophet Mohammed made with the Quraysh clan in Mecca”; Muslims took Mecca two years later. A tape of the speech was broadcast on Israel Radio.

    [24]Israel demands pledge from Arafat to uphold accord(opens another site in a new tab)[25]Remarks Attributed to Arafat Could Derail the Peace Process(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Efraim Karsh

    “For Yasir Arafat and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) leadership, the Oslo process has always been a strategic means not to a two-state solution … but to the substitution of a Palestinian state for the state of Israel.”

    [26]Arafat’s Grand Strategy(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Moshe Yaalon

    Writing in 2008, the former Israeli chief of staff described the PLO’s course under Arafat as a “two-faced strategy, in which diplomacy was harnessed in the service of the armed struggle against the Jewish state”.

    [27]Israel and the Palestinians: A New Strategy(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Factual claim

    In February 2022 the PLO’s Central Council “suspended … the recognition of the State of Israel until Israel recognizes the State of Palestine on the 4 June 1967 borders”.

    [28]Palestinian Central Council suspends recognition of Israel(opens another site in a new tab)
  6. Interpretation

    A movement that adopted a programme of liberation by stages, and whose leader likened the agreement with Israel to a truce the Prophet later ended, gave reason to read its recognition as a step rather than an end. Its suspension in 2022 shows the recognition was always conditional.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    In 1988 the Palestine National Council called for an international peace conference “on the basis of Security Council resolutions 242 (1967) and 338 (1973)”, and in December Arafat declared: “we totally and absolutely renounce all forms of terrorism”.

    [29]Peace process review: January 1988 – March 1991(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Yasser Arafat

    In Geneva on 14 December 1988: “Our desire for peace is a strategy and not an interim tactic.”

    [30]Statements by Yasir Arafat and George Shultz, December 14, 1988 (Quandt, Peace Process, Appendix K)(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Yasser Arafat

    After the Johannesburg speech, Arafat said that by “jihad” he meant a peaceful crusade, and explained that “it was the Quraysh who breached the pact with the prophet”.

    [24]Israel demands pledge from Arafat to uphold accord(opens another site in a new tab)[31]Palestinian Leader Attempts To Explain His Remarks(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Joel Singer

    The Israeli negotiator who drafted the 1993 letters wrote in 2021 that “the Mutual Recognition Agreement was intended to be permanent and it still stands”.

    [32]The Israel-PLO Mutual Recognition Agreement(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Position ·Rashid Khalidi

    The historian, on the PLO’s path from the 1974 programme to 1988: “Each of these was a step towards acceptance of Israel, acceptance of 242, acceptance of a two-state solution, renunciation of violence.”

    [33]Rashid Khalidi on Israel’s Long Reign of Violence(opens another site in a new tab)
  6. Position ·Mahmoud Abbas

    At the UN General Assembly in 2016: “our 1993 recognition of the existence of the State of Israel, a recognition which remains valid to this moment, is not a gratuitous recognition”.

    [34]Statement by President Mahmoud Abbas to the UN General Assembly, 2016(opens another site in a new tab)
  7. Interpretation

    The PLO’s path from 1974 to 1993 was a gradual move towards accepting Israel, made in writing and before the world. A speech meant to calm opponents at home does not undo a signed recognition that has stood for three decades. Its suspension in 2022 was a demand for reciprocity, not a return to 1974.

Point 3 of 8

Why is a “right to exist” asked of the Palestinians?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    At Khartoum in September 1967, the Arab states resolved on “no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with it”.

    [35]The Khartoum Resolutions, 1 September 1967(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Golda Meir

    As prime minister, in 1973: “the root issue is the Arab attitude to Israel’s very existence and security.”

    [36]Golda Meir, Israel in Search of Lasting Peace(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Yitzhak Rabin

    As prime minister, in 1977: “Recognition is a diplomatic act, but the essence of the question is reconciliation.”

    [37]Memorandum of conversation, President Carter and Prime Minister Rabin, 7 March 1977 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, vol. VIII, doc. 18)(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Barack Obama

    As President of the United States, in 2011: “any Palestinian partner must recognize Israel’s right to exist and reject violence”.

    [16]Addresses by President Barack Obama on the Middle East(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    A movement whose founding texts called Israel’s creation illegal could recognise the state as a fact while still aiming to undo it. Asking it to accept Israel’s right to exist asks it to give up that aim, which plain recognition does not.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Position ·John Whitbeck

    The international lawyer wrote in 2007 that asking Palestinians to recognise “Israel’s right to exist” is different from asking them to recognise its existence: “This formulation does not address diplomatic formalities or a simple acceptance of present realities. It calls for a moral judgment.”

    [38]What “Israel’s right to exist” means to Palestinians(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·John Dugard

    The international lawyer, a former UN special rapporteur, wrote in 2021: “The right of a State to exist is not a concept recognized by international law”, and that the demand asks Palestinians to “recognize the legality and morality of its creation”.

    [17]An Expert Opinion on the Question of Israel’s Right to Exist(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·PLO leaders

    As the US embassy in Beirut reported in August 1977, PLO leaders objected to a US demand because “in their view it requires them to go further in recognition of Israel than any Arab state”.

    [39]Telegram from the Embassy in Lebanon to Secretary of State Vance, 10 August 1977 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, vol. VIII, doc. 84)(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Mahmoud Abbas

    In 2011: “we have recognized Israel’s right to exist on the 1967 lines. I hope the Israeli government will reciprocate by recognizing the state of Palestine on 1967 borders.”

    [40]Israel Has to Recognize Palestinian State as We Recognized its Right to Exist(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    Palestinians can accept that Israel exists and live beside it in peace, as the PLO undertook in 1993. Asking them to affirm its right to exist asks them to approve how it came about, including their own dispossession, a demand rarely made of anyone else, and with nothing equivalent asked of Israel about a Palestinian state.

Point 4 of 8

Was the PLO’s Charter changed?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The resolution that the Palestine National Council adopted in 1996 cancelled “the articles that are contrary to the letters” of 1993 without naming them, and asked a legal committee to redraft the Charter.

    [5]1996 amendments to the PLO Charter(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    The Palestine National Council did not in fact amend any provision of the Charter.

    [41]Was the Palestine National Covenant amended?(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    A founding text is changed by adopting a new one. Three decades on there is a vote, a letter, and a show of hands, and no amended Charter that anyone can read. That is the mark of a commitment made for foreign audiences.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The Palestine National Council voted in April 1996, by 504 to 54 with 14 abstentions, to cancel the Charter’s articles that contradicted the 1993 letters.

    [41]Was the Palestine National Covenant amended?(opens another site in a new tab)[5]1996 amendments to the PLO Charter(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In January 1998 Arafat wrote to President Clinton listing the articles that had been nullified. In December 1998, in Gaza and with Clinton present, members of the Council raised their hands to confirm it.

    [42]Arafat letter of assurance affirming changes in the PLO Charter, January 1998(opens another site in a new tab)[6]Clinton watches as Palestinians vote to annul anti-Israel clauses(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    A two-thirds vote, a letter naming the articles, and a public confirmation before the American president amount to an amendment. That no new booklet was printed does not bring the cancelled articles back to life.

Point 5 of 8

What does recognising Israel “as a Jewish state” add?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Benjamin Netanyahu

    Israel’s Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, told the United Nations in 2011 that the core of the conflict “remains the refusal of the Palestinians to recognize a Jewish state in any border”.

    [10]Speech by Prime Minister Netanyahu at the United Nations General Assembly, 23 September 2011(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Mahmoud Abbas

    The Palestinian President, Mahmoud Abbas, said in 2009 of the term “a Jewish state”: “You can call yourselves as you like, but I don’t accept it and I say so publicly.”

    [11]Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    Israel was founded as the state of the Jewish people; that is what it is, not a label. To recognise “Israel” while refusing that is to keep open the aim of ending it by other means, above all by the return of millions of refugees’ descendants into Israel itself.

    [43]Abbas again says ‘We cannot recognize a Jewish state’(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The 1993 letter recognises “the State of Israel”. It does not contain the words “Jewish state”, and Israel accepted it as it stood.

    [4]Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin)(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Mahmoud Abbas

    In the same 2009 speech in which he refused the term “Jewish state”, President Abbas said: “We want a state on the 1967 borders, not a centimeter more, not a centimeter less.”

    [11]Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Mahmoud Abbas

    President Abbas has given his reasons. In April 2014 he said the Palestinians had recognised Israel as a state in 1993 and should not have to accept its religious identity. In December 2014 he told an Egyptian newspaper that recognising a Jewish state would harm Israel’s Arab citizens and close the door to refugees who wish to return. The second statement is known in English through a media monitoring group’s translation.

    [44]Abbas: Unity govt to reject violence(opens another site in a new tab)[43]Abbas again says ‘We cannot recognize a Jewish state’(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Palestinian officials

    Palestinian officials also object that Israel did not ask for recognition as a Jewish state in its peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan. An American scholar who considers the recognition necessary records this as one of their three stated objections.

    [45]Palestinian recognition of the Jewish state, by Robert O. Freedman(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    Recognising a state does not mean endorsing how it describes itself. The 1993 letters, which Israel accepted, do not ask for it. Accepting it would mean agreeing in advance that Palestinian citizens of Israel are lesser citizens, that the refugees have no claim, and that the events of 1948 were just. Refusing those words does not withdraw the sentence written in 1993.

Point 6 of 8

What does Hamas say?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Hamas

    Hamas’s founding Covenant of 1988 opens with the words “Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it”. It cites a saying that the Day of Judgement will not come “until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews)”, and it says there is “no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad”.

    [2]The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, 18 August 1988, Article 13(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Hamas

    Hamas’s document of 2017 says: “There shall be no recognition of the legitimacy of the Zionist entity.” It rejects “any alternative to the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea”.

    [7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)[46]حماس تعلن وثيقتها للمبادئ والسياسات العامة(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Ghazi Hamad

    A member of Hamas’s political bureau, Ghazi Hamad, said on Lebanese television in October 2023, in a translation by a media monitoring group: “Israel is a country that has no place on our land. We must remove that country.” Asked whether that meant the annihilation of Israel, he answered: “Yes, of course.”

    [47]Hamas official Ghazi Hamad: We will repeat the October 7 attack time and again until Israel is annihilated(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Factual claim

    Hamas won the Palestinian elections of 2006 and controlled the Gaza Strip from 2007, after forcing out its rival, Fatah.

    [48]Hamas accepts Palestinian state with 1967 borders(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    A movement that won an election and governed Gaza cannot be set aside as a fringe. Its 2017 wording about the 1967 lines is a stage on the way, as the same paragraph says, to the whole.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    Hamas is not part of the PLO and did not sign the 1993 letters. Its 2017 document rejects the Oslo agreements that followed them.

    [7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Hamas

    Hamas’s 2017 document says that its conflict “is with the Zionist project not with the Jews because of their religion”. It describes a Palestinian state on the lines of 4 June 1967, with the return of refugees, as “a formula of national consensus”, while refusing to recognise Israel.

    [7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)[48]Hamas accepts Palestinian state with 1967 borders(opens another site in a new tab)[46]حماس تعلن وثيقتها للمبادئ والسياسات العامة(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Azzam Tamimi

    Azzam Tamimi, a historian of the movement, said at the time that the 2017 document would “practically” replace the 1988 Covenant; Hamas itself has not said so.

    [48]Hamas accepts Palestinian state with 1967 borders(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Interpretation

    Hamas speaks for Hamas. Treating its documents as the position of “the Palestinians” ignores the PLO’s recognition and everyone who does not support Hamas. Even Hamas moved in 2017 from a religious war against Jews towards a political dispute over land.

Point 7 of 8

What do Palestinians tell pollsters?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    In August 2026 the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research found that 44% of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza supported a two-state solution and 50% opposed it. Gallup found in 2026 that 58% of Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem did not support one.

    [49]Public Opinion Poll No. 97(opens another site in a new tab)[50]Most Israelis, Palestinians do not want two-state solution(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In a poll by the same institute in mid-2024, two thirds of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza said that Hamas’s decision to launch the attack of 7 October 2023 was correct; the figure had been 72% in December 2023.

    [51]Public Opinion Poll No. 92(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    A public that does not want a state beside Israel has not accepted that Israel is there to stay.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    In the same August 2026 poll, 56% preferred a two-state arrangement based on the 1967 lines when it was offered alongside other options. In a September 2024 poll, 59% supported “the establishment of an independent Palestinian state on the territories occupied in 1967”.

    [49]Public Opinion Poll No. 97(opens another site in a new tab)[52]Palestinian Peace Coalition poll summary, September 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In that poll, 58% said a two-state solution was no longer practical because of the expansion of Israeli settlements, and support for armed struggle as the best way to achieve a state had fallen from about four in ten to under three in ten.

    [49]Public Opinion Poll No. 97(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    None of these polls asks whether Israel should exist. Approving of an attack, in the middle of a war, is not an answer to that question either. The polls ask about a peace plan, and many of those who say no think the plan is no longer achievable, not that Israel should disappear. When the question is a state on the 1967 lines, which leaves Israel in place, most say yes.

Point 8 of 8

What do the slogan and the schoolbooks show?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    A study of Palestinian Authority schoolbooks funded by the European Union found that maps of the region “do not show Israel”, that cities founded by Jews such as Tel Aviv are not marked, and that Israel “is seldom mentioned by name”.

    [53]Report on Palestinian Textbooks: answers to frequently asked questions(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Georg Eckert Institute

    The same study found that the textbooks also contain “portrayals that defend, or even support, violence against Israelis”. Violence against Israeli civilians in attacks of the 1970s “is not condemned but rather portrayed as a legitimate method of the struggle during that period”, and attacks such as Dalal al-Mughrabi’s are recounted as examples of “self-sacrificing ‘resistance’”.

    [53]Report on Palestinian Textbooks: answers to frequently asked questions(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    “From the river to the sea” names the whole territory, with no Israel in it. Hamas uses the phrase in exactly that sense, and two Israeli historians who defend the slogan’s other meanings accept that some who chant it envisage the expulsion or murder of Jews.

    [7]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20(opens another site in a new tab)[12]‘From the river to the sea’: One slogan, many meanings, by Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The EU-commissioned study of Palestinian Authority schoolbooks, by Germany’s Georg Eckert Institute, found no direct calls for violence against Israelis in the books it analysed.

    [53]Report on Palestinian Textbooks: answers to frequently asked questions(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino

    According to two Israeli historians, Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino, the slogan “from the river to the sea” spread in the 1960s, when it meant “a secular, democratic and egalitarian state in all of Palestine, in which Jews would enjoy full equal rights”.

    [12]‘From the river to the sea’: One slogan, many meanings, by Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    A slogan means what the person using it means. For most Palestinians it is a call for freedom across a land where they live under another’s rule, not for anyone’s removal. What a schoolbook map leaves out does not settle what people will accept in an agreement.

Sources

  1. The Palestinian National Charter: Resolutions of the Palestine National Council, July 1-17, 1968, Article 19 (opens another site)Avalon Project, Yale Law School
  2. The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, 18 August 1988, Article 13 (opens another site)Avalon Project, Yale Law School
  3. Palestinian Declaration of Independence, Algiers, 15 November 1988 (opens another site)Text published by the Foundation for Middle East Peace
  4. Text of mutual recognition letters (Arafat to Rabin) (opens another site)Jewish Telegraphic Agency
  5. 1996 amendments to the PLO Charter (opens another site)Text published by the Institute for Middle East Understanding
  6. Clinton watches as Palestinians vote to annul anti-Israel clauses (opens another site)Los Angeles Times
  7. Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 20 (opens another site)Text published by Middle East Eye
  8. PLO Central Council statement, 15 January 2018 (opens another site)Text published by the Jewish Virtual Library
  9. PLO votes to suspend recognition of Israel until it recognizes Palestinian state (opens another site)Haaretz
  10. Speech by Prime Minister Netanyahu at the United Nations General Assembly, 23 September 2011 (opens another site)Text published by the Jewish Virtual Library
  11. Abbas won’t recognize Israel as Jewish state (opens another site)Jewish Telegraphic Agency
  12. ‘From the river to the sea’: One slogan, many meanings, by Amos Goldberg and Alon Confino (opens another site)Review of Democracy, Central European University
  13. Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Nations, American Institute of International Law, 6 January 1916, in Documents of the United Nations Conference on International Organization, vol. III (opens another site)United Nations
  14. Draft Declaration on Rights and Duties of States, with commentaries (opens another site)United NationsArchived copy (opens another site)
  15. Statement on Diplomatic Talks With the Palestine Liberation Organization, 14 December 1988 (opens another site)Ronald Reagan Presidential Library
  16. Addresses by President Barack Obama on the Middle East (opens another site)The Cairo Review of Global Affairs
  17. An Expert Opinion on the Question of Israel’s Right to Exist (opens another site)European Legal Support Center
  18. Jure Vidmar, The Concept of the State and its Right of Existence, Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law 4(3) (opens another site)Cambridge International Law Journal
  19. Israel Lauded in U.S. Congress; Greeted on Its Fourth Anniversary (opens another site)Jewish Telegraphic Agency
  20. Memorandum of Agreement between the Governments of Israel and the United States, 1 September 1975 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, vol. XXVI, doc. 227) (opens another site)Office of the Historian, US Department of State
  21. Statement to the Knesset by Prime Minister Begin upon the presentation of his government, 20 June 1977 (opens another site)Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel
  22. Abba Eban on Israel’s “Right to Exist” (from The New York Times, 18 November 1981) (opens another site)Jewish Virtual Library
  23. Political Programme of 9 June 1974, 12th Palestine National Council (opens another site)Palestine National Council, text published by the United Nations
  24. Israel demands pledge from Arafat to uphold accord (opens another site)The Baltimore Sun
  25. Remarks Attributed to Arafat Could Derail the Peace Process (opens another site)Jewish Telegraphic Agency
  26. Arafat’s Grand Strategy (opens another site)Middle East Quarterly (Middle East Forum)
  27. Israel and the Palestinians: A New Strategy (opens another site)Azure (Shalem Center)
  28. Palestinian Central Council suspends recognition of Israel (opens another site)WAFA (Palestinian news agency)
  29. Peace process review: January 1988 – March 1991 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
  30. Statements by Yasir Arafat and George Shultz, December 14, 1988 (Quandt, Peace Process, Appendix K) (opens another site)Brookings Institution
  31. Palestinian Leader Attempts To Explain His Remarks (opens another site)The Christian Science Monitor
  32. The Israel-PLO Mutual Recognition Agreement (opens another site)International Negotiation (Brill), copy hosted by the Center for Israel Education
  33. Rashid Khalidi on Israel’s Long Reign of Violence (opens another site)The Intercept
  34. Statement by President Mahmoud Abbas to the UN General Assembly, 2016 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
  35. The Khartoum Resolutions, 1 September 1967 (opens another site)Jewish Virtual Library
  36. Golda Meir, Israel in Search of Lasting Peace (opens another site)Foreign Affairs
  37. Memorandum of conversation, President Carter and Prime Minister Rabin, 7 March 1977 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, vol. VIII, doc. 18) (opens another site)Office of the Historian, US Department of State
  38. What “Israel’s right to exist” means to Palestinians (opens another site)The Christian Science Monitor
  39. Telegram from the Embassy in Lebanon to Secretary of State Vance, 10 August 1977 (Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, vol. VIII, doc. 84) (opens another site)Office of the Historian, US Department of State
  40. Israel Has to Recognize Palestinian State as We Recognized its Right to Exist (opens another site)WAFA (Palestinian news agency)
  41. Was the Palestine National Covenant amended? (opens another site)Law and Israel
  42. Arafat letter of assurance affirming changes in the PLO Charter, January 1998 (opens another site)Text published by the Jewish Virtual Library
  43. Abbas again says ‘We cannot recognize a Jewish state’ (opens another site)JNS, published by The Algemeiner
  44. Abbas: Unity govt to reject violence (opens another site)Arab News
  45. Palestinian recognition of the Jewish state, by Robert O. Freedman (opens another site)Middle East Strategy at Harvard
  46. حماس تعلن وثيقتها للمبادئ والسياسات العامة (opens another site)Al Jazeera (Arabic)
  47. Hamas official Ghazi Hamad: We will repeat the October 7 attack time and again until Israel is annihilated (opens another site)Middle East Media Research Institute
  48. Hamas accepts Palestinian state with 1967 borders (opens another site)Al Jazeera
  49. Public Opinion Poll No. 97 (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
  50. Most Israelis, Palestinians do not want two-state solution (opens another site)Gallup
  51. Public Opinion Poll No. 92 (opens another site)Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
  52. Palestinian Peace Coalition poll summary, September 2024 (opens another site)Palestinian Peace Coalition (Geneva Initiative); poll conducted by the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research
  53. Report on Palestinian Textbooks: answers to frequently asked questions (opens another site)Georg Eckert Institute for International Textbook Research
  54. EU study finds incitement in Palestinian textbooks, kept from public (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post

All the sources this site uses →

Change history

  • A passage added for the 59% support for a Palestinian state on the territories occupied in 1967 (September 2024).
  • The note on “a right to exist” now also says that the United States kept the condition, in 1988 and 2011; the 1977 report of PLO leaders’ objection is shown as their position; the Johannesburg statement cites the passages naming the mosque, the jihad and Jerusalem. Raised in the review of the new point.
  • New point, “Why is a ‘right to exist’ asked of the Palestinians?”, with the case for the demand and the case against it, and a note on the phrase: its use in international law since 1916, its use as a condition for the PLO from 1975, and Begin’s and Eban’s view that Israel need not ask for it. Raised by a reader.
  • The schoolbooks point now names the study, the EU-commissioned study by the Georg Eckert Institute, in the Palestinian column and in its mark.
  • The schoolbooks point: the statement that the EU-commissioned study found no direct calls for violence is now marked as misleading, since the same study found portrayals that defend or support violence against Israelis. Raised by a reader.
  • New point, “Was the recognition meant to last?”: the argument that the PLO’s recognition of Israel was a step in a longer struggle, with the 1974 programme and Arafat’s Johannesburg speech, and the answer that it was a lasting change, with the 1988 statements, the Israeli negotiator Joel Singer and President Abbas. Raised by a reader.
  • The schoolbooks point now gives the whole finding of the EU-commissioned study: beside “no direct calls for violence”, its finding of portrayals that defend or support violence against Israelis (a20). Raised by a reader.
  • Abbas’s reasons (b22) and Palestinian officials’ objection (b23) shown as their positions.
  • Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two.
  • Added a background box, “The main texts”: seven dated texts and votes, from the PLO charter of 1968 to the Central Council’s 2018 decision, all from sources already on the page.
  • The question was reworded so that it no longer puts an accusation to one people: “Have the Palestinians accepted Israel’s existence, and in what terms?”
  • Added President Abbas's stated reasons for refusing "Jewish state", and an Arabic source for the Hamas document.
  • First published.