Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 7 · The war in Gaza · question 3 of 4

What has the International Court of Justice decided in South Africa’s genocide case against Israel?

Last reviewed

Background · 7 key momentsHow the case has unfoldedNew to the subject? Start here.
  1. 29 December 2023

    South Africa brought a case against Israel at the International Court of Justice under the Genocide Convention, and asked for urgent measures. Hearings were held on 11 and 12 January 2024. [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)

  2. 26 January 2024

    By fifteen votes to two, the Court ordered Israel to take all measures within its power to prevent acts covered by the Convention. It did not order a halt to the fighting, and it did not rule on whether genocide had taken place. [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)

  3. 16 February 2024

    The Court declined South Africa’s request for further urgent measures over Rafah. [2]Top UN court denies South African request for urgent Rafah safeguards(opens another site in a new tab)

  4. 28 March 2024

    Finding that famine was setting in, the Court ordered Israel to ensure the unhindered provision, at scale, of urgently needed basic services and humanitarian aid in Gaza. [3]Order of 28 March 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 21(opens another site in a new tab)

  5. 24 May 2024

    The Court ordered Israel to halt immediately its offensive in Rafah, and any other action there, which may inflict on the Palestinians in Gaza conditions of life that could bring about their physical destruction in whole or in part. [4]Order of 24 May 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 57(opens another site in a new tab)

  6. 12 March 2026

    Israel filed its response to South Africa’s case. [5]South Africa notes Israel’s response filing to the ICJ(opens another site in a new tab)

  7. Until 2029

    Further written rounds are scheduled, with Israel’s last filing due by 22 May 2029. The Court will rule on whether genocide took place only after that. [6]Presidency notes ICJ Order of 21 May 2026(opens another site in a new tab)

In brief

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

The Court found that Palestinians in Gaza face a real and imminent risk to their right to be protected from genocide, and it has placed Israel under binding orders three times, including an order to halt its offensive in Rafah.

The Court found the conditions for emergency orders met, refused Israel’s request to throw the case out, and ordered Israel to prevent genocidal acts and let aid in. In March 2024 it found famine setting in and tightened its orders unanimously. In May 2024 it ordered a halt to the offensive in Rafah. These orders are binding. No final judgment exists, and none is due before 2029.

Where this is argued: [7]Statement by South Africa welcoming the provisional measures ordered by the International Court of Justice against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)[8]President Cyril Ramaphosa: Ruling of the International Court of Justice, 26 January 2024(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of Israel’s position

The Court has found nothing against Israel: it has not found genocide or even a plausible case of it, it refused to order a ceasefire, and its interim orders only restate duties Israel already accepts.

The Court said in terms that it was not deciding whether Israel had breached the Genocide Convention. What it called plausible was a set of rights, not the accusation, as the judge who presided has since said publicly. South Africa asked for a halt to the war and was refused three times. The Rafah order of May 2024 forbids only action that would threaten the group’s destruction. Two judges dissented, and the case itself has years to run.

Where this is argued: [9]Joint statement by the head of Israel’s National Security Council and the spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)[10]Dissenting opinion of Judge ad hoc Barak, Order of 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)

What it turns on: Both sides agree that the Court has not ruled on whether Israel has committed genocide, and will not for years. They disagree on what its interim orders mean: whether finding a right “plausible” and at risk says anything about the accusation itself, and whether the orders required Israel to stop fighting, in Gaza or in Rafah.

A note on terms

Everything the Court has decided so far is an order on “provisional measures”: an interim order made at the start of a case to protect the rights in dispute until the final judgment. Such an order is not a verdict, and this page does not call it a “ruling”. The stage at which the Court decides whether the accusation is true is called “the merits”. [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)

The case is brought under the 1948 Genocide Convention, to which both South Africa and Israel are parties. Whether Israel’s conduct in Gaza is genocide is the subject of a separate page; this one is only about what the Court has and has not decided. [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)

Point by point

Point 1 of 5

What did the Court find “plausible”?

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The Court found the conditions for interim orders met, including “a real and imminent risk that irreparable prejudice will be caused” to the rights at stake before it gives its final decision. It adopted most of its measures by fifteen votes to two.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·South African government

    South Africa’s government said that the Court had “determined that Israel’s actions in Gaza are plausibly genocidal”. Its President said that the effect of the order “is that there is a plausible case of genocide”.

    [7]Statement by South Africa welcoming the provisional measures ordered by the International Court of Justice against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)[8]President Cyril Ramaphosa: Ruling of the International Court of Justice, 26 January 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Roy Schöndorf

    Roy Schöndorf, Israel’s deputy attorney general for international law until 2022, who thinks the order was widely misreported, nonetheless describes what the Court found as this: South Africa invoked rights set out in the Convention and “presented factual arguments that purported to at least partially correspond with those rights”.

    [11]Implausible confusion: the meaning of “plausibility” in the ICJ’s provisional measures(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Interpretation

    The right the Court found plausible is the right of Palestinians in Gaza to be protected from genocide, and it found that right at real and imminent risk. A court does not issue emergency orders against a state, by fifteen votes to two, over a risk it considers fanciful. “Plausible genocide” is a fair summary of that.

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    In its first order the Court said that, at that stage, it “is not required to ascertain whether any violations of Israel’s obligations under the Genocide Convention have occurred”.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    What the order describes as plausible is “at least some of the rights claimed by South Africa”. It does not say that genocide, or South Africa’s accusation, is plausible.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Joan Donoghue

    The judge who presided over the Court when it made that order, Joan Donoghue, said in April 2024 that the Court “did not decide that the claim of genocide was plausible”, and that she was correcting what was often said in the media.

    [12]Former ICJ President clarifies court’s ruling on South Africa’s case against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Interpretation

    The test at this stage is a low one. Palestinians plainly have a right to be protected from genocide, and the Court found only that this right is in play and at risk. To report that as a finding of “plausible genocide” turns a procedural threshold into a verdict.

Point 2 of 5

Did the Court order the fighting to stop?

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The Court ordered Israel to “take all measures within its power to prevent the commission of all acts within the scope of Article II” of the Genocide Convention against Palestinians in Gaza.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    In March 2024 the Court observed that famine was “setting in” in Gaza, and ordered Israel, unanimously, to ensure “the unhindered provision at scale” of basic services and humanitarian aid.

    [3]Order of 28 March 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 21(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    The Court did not use the word “ceasefire”, but it ordered results that cannot be had without one. As South Africa’s foreign minister put it: “If you read the order, by implication, a ceasefire must happen.”

    [13]World reacts to ICJ interim ruling in Gaza genocide case against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    South Africa asked the Court to order that Israel “immediately suspend its military operations in and against Gaza”. The Court did not order this in January, February, or March 2024.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)[10]Dissenting opinion of Judge ad hoc Barak, Order of 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Top UN court denies South African request for urgent Rafah safeguards(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·US government

    The United States said on the day of the first order that the Court “did not make a finding about genocide or call for a ceasefire”.

    [13]World reacts to ICJ interim ruling in Gaza genocide case against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    Between January and March 2024 the Court was asked three times to stop the war and each time declined. What it ordered instead, to prevent genocidal acts and let aid in, restates duties Israel already had and says it observes.

Point 3 of 5

What does the Rafah order of May 2024 require?

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    On 24 May 2024 the Court ordered Israel, by thirteen votes to two, to “immediately halt its military offensive, and any other action in the Rafah Governorate, which may inflict on the Palestinian group in Gaza conditions of life that could bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part”.

    [4]Order of 24 May 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 57(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Dire Tladi

    Judge Dire Tladi, who voted for the order, wrote: “Today, the Court has, in explicit terms, ordered the State of Israel to halt its offensive in Rafah.”

    [14]Declaration of Judge Tladi, Order of 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Factual claim

    In the same order the Court found that “the current situation arising from Israel’s military offensive in Rafah entails a further risk of irreparable prejudice” to the rights at stake.

    [4]Order of 24 May 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 57(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Interpretation

    The offensive is what must halt. The qualifying words describe the “other action” that is also forbidden, which is why they come after it. Having found that the offensive itself created the risk, the Court cannot have meant to leave it free to continue; an order that did so would have ordered nothing.

    [15]President Cyril Ramaphosa welcomes new ICJ orders in aid of Rafah, 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Aharon Barak

    The judge appointed by Israel, Aharon Barak, wrote that the May 2024 measure requires Israel to halt its offensive in Rafah “only in so far as is necessary to comply with Israel’s obligations under the Genocide Convention”.

    [10]Dissenting opinion of Judge ad hoc Barak, Order of 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Israeli government

    Israel’s government responded the same day that it “has not and will not conduct military actions in the Rafah area which may inflict on the Palestinian civilian population in Gaza conditions of life that could bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part”.

    [9]Joint statement by the head of Israel’s National Security Council and the spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 24 May 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    The words “which may inflict … conditions of life that could bring about its physical destruction” govern the whole sentence. The order forbids an offensive of that kind; it does not forbid Israel to fight Hamas in Rafah. South Africa had asked for an unqualified withdrawal and did not get it.

    [4]Order of 24 May 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 57(opens another site in a new tab)

Point 4 of 5

Are the orders binding, and what do they settle?

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The Court stated that its orders on provisional measures “have binding effect and thus create international legal obligations” for the state they are addressed to.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)[7]Statement by South Africa welcoming the provisional measures ordered by the International Court of Justice against Israel(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Israel is under three binding orders of the highest United Nations court in a genocide case. That is a legal fact about its conduct now, not a matter to be settled years from today, and other states have their own duty to prevent genocide once they know of a serious risk.

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The Court said its first order “in no way prejudges” whether it has jurisdiction over the merits, whether the application is admissible, or the merits themselves.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Binding is not the same as breached. An interim order creates a duty to act with care while the case is heard; it is not a finding that the duty has been broken, and no court has found that Israel has broken it.

Point 5 of 5

Where does the case stand?

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    Israel asked the Court to remove the case from its list. The Court refused.

    [1]Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    The case continues. In May 2026 the Court set 22 November 2027 for South Africa’s reply and 22 May 2029 for Israel’s rejoinder; a judgment on whether Israel has committed genocide is not expected before then.

    [6]Presidency notes ICJ Order of 21 May 2026(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Julia Sebutinde

    Judge Julia Sebutinde, one of the two of seventeen judges who voted against most of the first order’s measures, wrote that South Africa “has not demonstrated, even on a prima facie basis”, that the acts it complained of were committed with genocidal intent.

    [16]Dissenting opinion of Judge Sebutinde, Order of 26 January 2024(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    Israel filed its written response to South Africa’s case in March 2026.

    [5]South Africa notes Israel’s response filing to the ICJ(opens another site in a new tab)

Sources

  1. Order of 26 January 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 1 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, copy published by Just Security
  2. Top UN court denies South African request for urgent Rafah safeguards (opens another site)Associated Press, published by CBC
  3. Order of 28 March 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 21 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
  4. Order of 24 May 2024, South Africa v. Israel, paragraph 57 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
  5. South Africa notes Israel’s response filing to the ICJ (opens another site)Department of International Relations and Cooperation, South Africa
  6. Presidency notes ICJ Order of 21 May 2026 (opens another site)The Presidency, Republic of South Africa
  7. Statement by South Africa welcoming the provisional measures ordered by the International Court of Justice against Israel (opens another site)Department of International Relations and Cooperation, South Africa
  8. President Cyril Ramaphosa: Ruling of the International Court of Justice, 26 January 2024 (opens another site)Government of South Africa
  9. Joint statement by the head of Israel’s National Security Council and the spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 24 May 2024 (opens another site)Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel
  10. Dissenting opinion of Judge ad hoc Barak, Order of 24 May 2024 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
  11. Implausible confusion: the meaning of “plausibility” in the ICJ’s provisional measures (opens another site)EJIL: Talk!, blog of the European Journal of International Law
  12. Former ICJ President clarifies court’s ruling on South Africa’s case against Israel (opens another site)The Jerusalem Post
  13. World reacts to ICJ interim ruling in Gaza genocide case against Israel (opens another site)Al Jazeera
  14. Declaration of Judge Tladi, Order of 24 May 2024 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
  15. President Cyril Ramaphosa welcomes new ICJ orders in aid of Rafah, 24 May 2024 (opens another site)Government of South Africa
  16. Dissenting opinion of Judge Sebutinde, Order of 26 January 2024 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations

All the sources this site uses →

Change history

  • The Israeli government’s reply on Rafah (a9) shown as a position.
  • Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two. Corrected: the analysis of what the Court found is by one legal scholar, Roy Schöndorf, formerly Israel’s deputy attorney general for international law, not two.
  • Added a background box, “How the case has unfolded”: seven dated steps from South Africa’s filing in December 2023 to the written rounds due to end in 2029, with one new source (the January 2024 order, paragraph 1).
  • First published.