Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 4 · The language of armed conflict
Should Hamas’s actions be considered resistance or terrorism?
Last reviewed
In brief
Argued in support of Israel’s position
Hamas’s actions are terrorism: it deliberately attacks civilians to achieve political ends, and no cause makes that anything else.
The law of war forbids spreading terror among civilians, and the Security Council has said such acts can never be justified by a political cause. Hamas has fired rockets at towns, and on 7 October 2023 it killed hundreds of civilians and took hostages, as a United Nations inquiry and human rights organisations have found. It claims a right to use “all means”. The United States, the United Kingdom, and others list it as a terrorist organisation, and more states at the United Nations voted to condemn it than voted against.
Where this is argued: [1]U.S. resolution to condemn Hamas militants fails at U.N.(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Islamist terrorist group Hamas banned in the UK(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
Hamas’s actions are resistance: Palestinians are a people under occupation with a recognised right to struggle against it, including by force, and “terrorism” is the name their adversaries give to that struggle.
The General Assembly has affirmed the legitimacy of peoples’ struggle against foreign occupation “by all available means, including armed struggle”, and named the Palestinians. The Geneva Protocol treats such struggles as international armed conflicts, fought under the laws of war. The law of war has no definition of terrorism and does not forbid attacks on soldiers. A condemnation of Hamas failed to win the required majority at the General Assembly in 2018; terrorist listings are the acts of individual governments. Liberation movements from South Africa onward were called terrorist until they won.
Where this is argued: [3]The right of the Palestinian people to resist(opens another site in a new tab)[4]“We stand ready to be one of the guarantors of Palestine”(opens another site in a new tab)[5]Palestinians have a legal right to armed struggle, by Stanley L. Cohen(opens another site in a new tab)
What it turns on: Both sides agree that Hamas has attacked Israeli soldiers and that Israeli civilians have been killed in its attacks, and that the law of war forbids attacking civilians. They disagree on which of these defines Hamas, on whether a people under occupation has a right to fight and what that right permits, and on whether one word can settle it at all.
A note on terms
There is no single definition of “terrorism” accepted by all states. Governments define it in their own laws, and the law of war forbids particular acts without using the word as a category. On this page, a statement that uses the word says, or shows by its source, whose meaning it relies on. [6]What does humanitarian law say about terrorism?(opens another site in a new tab)[7]Report of the Global Parliamentary Conference, Istanbul 2025(opens another site in a new tab)
The position shown here is the argument that Hamas’s actions are resistance. Not everyone who supports the Palestinian cause makes it: South Africa’s government, for one, condemned the attack of 7 October. “Hamas’s actions” covers very different things: attacks on soldiers and military posts, attacks on civilians, hostage-taking, and governing Gaza. Each statement on this page says which it means. Whether Gaza remained occupied after Israel withdrew in 2005 is itself disputed, and each side’s position on it is given. [8]Statement on the Cabinet meeting of 18 October 2023(opens another site in a new tab)[9]Advisory opinion of 19 July 2024 on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, paragraph 94(opens another site in a new tab)[10]Israel claims it is no longer occupying the Gaza Strip. What does international law say?(opens another site in a new tab)
Point by point
Point 1 of 5
What do the two words mean, and can both apply?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
The 1977 Protocol to the Geneva Conventions forbids “acts or threats of violence the primary purpose of which is to spread terror among the civilian population”. It makes no exception for the cause being fought for.
[11]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I), 8 June 1977, Article 51(2)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The United Nations Security Council said in 2004 that attacks on civilians and hostage-taking, carried out to terrorise a population or to force a government’s hand, “are under no circumstances justifiable” by political or other considerations.
[12]United Nations Security Council resolution 1566 (2004)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Terrorism is the name of a method: violence aimed at civilians in order to frighten a society into giving way. A cause, however it is described, does not change what the method is. Hamas has not only fought soldiers; it has made that method a repeated practice, and that is what the word describes.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Position ·Hamas
Hamas describes itself as “a Palestinian Islamic national liberation and resistance movement”.
[13]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The International Committee of the Red Cross notes that the law of war contains no definition of “terrorism”, and that its ban on spreading terror among civilians does “not prohibit lawful attacks on military targets”.
[6]What does humanitarian law say about terrorism?(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
“Terrorism” has no agreed meaning in law, which is why it serves so well as a label: the stronger party applies it to the weaker and the argument is over. “Resistance” names what the fighting is about. A people living under another’s military control does not become terrorist by taking up arms against it.
Point 2 of 5
Is there a right to resist, and what are its limits?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Israel’s position is that it ceased to occupy Gaza in 2005, when it withdrew all its soldiers and settlers.
[10]Israel claims it is no longer occupying the Gaza Strip. What does international law say?(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Hamas
Hamas’s 2017 document claims a right to resist “with all means and methods”. Its founding Covenant of 1988 says there is “no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad”.
[13]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab)[14]The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, 18 August 1988, Article 13(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Hamas
The same 2017 document says “There shall be no recognition of the legitimacy of the Zionist entity”, and rejects any alternative to “the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea”.
[13]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
A General Assembly resolution endorsing a people’s struggle is a political statement, not a treaty, and it does not set aside the laws of war. Those laws forbid attacks on civilians to every party, whatever its cause. Hamas invokes the first and ignores the second.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The United Nations General Assembly has reaffirmed “the legitimacy of the struggle of peoples for independence … and liberation from colonial and foreign domination and foreign occupation by all available means, including armed struggle”, in a 1982 resolution that names the Palestinian people.
[15]General Assembly resolution 37/43, 3 December 1982, paragraph 2(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The 1977 Protocol to the Geneva Conventions treats as international armed conflicts those in which peoples fight “against colonial domination and alien occupation” in the exercise of their right of self-determination.
[11]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I), 8 June 1977, Article 51(2)(opens another site in a new tab)[16]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I), 8 June 1977, Article 1(4)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The International Court of Justice said in 2024 that Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza in 2005 “has not entirely released it of its obligations under the law of occupation”, because it kept control of Gaza’s borders, airspace, and sea.
[9]Advisory opinion of 19 July 2024 on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, paragraph 94(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·ICRC
The International Committee of the Red Cross considers that Israel has occupied Gaza, with the West Bank and East Jerusalem, since 1967, and that Gaza remained occupied after 2005 because Israel kept effective control over it.
[17]What does the law say about the responsibilities of the Occupying Power in the occupied Palestinian territory?(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Hamas
Hamas’s 2017 document also describes a fully sovereign Palestinian state on the lines of 4 June 1967, with the return of refugees, as “a formula of national consensus”.
[13]Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 1(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Israel has controlled the Palestinian territories since 1967 and, as the Court found, kept key elements of that control over Gaza after 2005. International law recognises their right to self-determination and the legitimacy of struggling for it, including by force. To call that struggle terrorism is to deny the right while claiming to object only to the method.
Point 3 of 5
Whom have Hamas’s attacks targeted?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
Of the 1,195 people killed in the attack of 7 October 2023, 815 were civilians, by a count of the news agency Agence France-Presse reported by Human Rights Watch.
[18]October 7 crimes against humanity, war crimes by Hamas-led groups(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Human Rights Watch
Human Rights Watch concluded that killing civilians and taking hostages “were central aims of the planned attack”.
[18]October 7 crimes against humanity, war crimes by Hamas-led groups(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·UN Commission of Inquiry
A United Nations commission of inquiry found in June 2024 that Hamas’s armed wing and six other Palestinian armed groups were responsible for “the war crimes of intentionally directing attacks against civilians”, and that members of Palestinian armed groups “deliberately killed, injured, mistreated, took hostages and committed sexual and gender-based violence against civilians”.
[19]Gaza: Hamas, Israel committed war crimes, claims independent rights probe(opens another site in a new tab)[20]Israeli authorities, Palestinian armed groups are responsible for war crimes, other grave violations of international law, UN Inquiry finds(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Human Rights Watch
Human Rights Watch said in 2009 that Hamas’s rocket attacks targeting Israeli civilians “are unlawful and unjustifiable, and amount to war crimes”.
[21]Gaza/Israel: Hamas rocket attacks on civilians unlawful(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Human Rights Watch recorded in 2002 that since October 2000 Hamas had carried out eighteen suicide attacks against civilians, more than any other Palestinian group.
[22]Erased in a moment: suicide bombing attacks against Israeli civilians, chapter IV(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Suicide bombings, rockets fired at towns, and the killings and abductions of 7 October were aimed at civilians. That Hamas has also attacked soldiers does not turn those attacks into something else.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The United Nations commission of inquiry recorded that the attack of 7 October was launched “against Israeli civilian targets and military bases”.
[23]Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry (A/HRC/56/26)(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·BADIL
A Palestinian rights organisation that defends the right to armed resistance writes that in such a struggle “International Humanitarian Law (IHL) must be respected”.
[3]The right of the Palestinian people to resist(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Under the law of war, attacks on the soldiers, bases, and military posts of an occupying army are not terrorism. Attacks on civilians are crimes, and those who defend the right to resist do not have to defend them. A movement is not defined by its worst acts any more than an army is.
- Position ·Hamas
Hamas’s own account of the attack is that on 7 October 2023 its fighters targeted military sites and soldiers, and that where civilians were targeted, “it happened accidentally”.
[24]Hamas says October 7 attack was a ‘necessary step’, admits to ‘some faults’(opens another site in a new tab)
Point 4 of 5
Who calls Hamas a terrorist organisation?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
The United States designated Hamas a foreign terrorist organisation in 1997. The United Kingdom banned its armed wing in 2001 and the organisation “in its entirety” in 2021.
[26]Designation of foreign terrorist organizations, Federal Register, 8 October 1997(opens another site in a new tab)[27]Home Secretary to ban Hamas from UK(opens another site in a new tab)[2]Islamist terrorist group Hamas banned in the UK(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
In December 2018 a draft resolution of the United Nations General Assembly condemning Hamas for firing rockets into Israel received 87 votes in favour and 57 against, with 33 abstentions.
[28]General Assembly reiterates call for Middle East peace after failing to pass resolution condemning Hamas(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The governments that list Hamas do so because of what it has done. That more states voted to condemn it than voted against, and that the text still failed on a procedural threshold, says something about the United Nations, not about Hamas.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The General Assembly draft of December 2018 condemning Hamas was not adopted: it fell short of the two-thirds majority the Assembly had required.
[28]General Assembly reiterates call for Middle East peace after failing to pass resolution condemning Hamas(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Recep Tayyip Erdoğan
Turkey’s President, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, said in October 2023: “Hamas is not a terrorist organization; it is a group of liberation and mujahedeen fighting to defend its lands and citizens.”
[4]“We stand ready to be one of the guarantors of Palestine”(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
A terrorist listing is a decision by one government under its own law. A listing of the whole movement treats attacks on soldiers exactly as it treats attacks on civilians, which is the distinction the law of war draws. When a condemnation of Hamas was put to the General Assembly, where every state sits, it did not reach the majority required.
Point 5 of 5
What do the historical comparisons show?
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Interpretation
The comparison with Nelson Mandela proves less than it seems. That some governments called a liberation movement terrorist does not show that the word is always misused. Whether it fits is decided by the acts in each case, and the deliberate killing of civilians is the act it names.
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Position ·Margaret Thatcher
Britain’s Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher called the African National Congress “a typical terrorist organisation” in 1987.
[29]Margaret Thatcher branded ANC ‘terrorist’ while urging Nelson Mandela’s release(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Nelson Mandela and other members of the African National Congress remained on United States terrorism watch lists until 2008.
[30]Kerry, Corker, Whitehouse announce Nelson Mandela will be removed from terror watch lists(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Movements that fought foreign or minority rule have often been called terrorist by the powers they fought, and later received as governments. The word has followed the balance of power at least as much as the acts.
Sources
- U.S. resolution to condemn Hamas militants fails at U.N. (opens another site)CBS News / Associated Press
- Islamist terrorist group Hamas banned in the UK (opens another site)Home Office, United Kingdom
- The right of the Palestinian people to resist (opens another site)BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights
- “We stand ready to be one of the guarantors of Palestine” (opens another site)Directorate of Communications, Presidency of the Republic of Türkiye
- Palestinians have a legal right to armed struggle, by Stanley L. Cohen (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- What does humanitarian law say about terrorism? (opens another site)International Committee of the Red Cross
- Report of the Global Parliamentary Conference, Istanbul 2025 (opens another site)United Nations Office of Counter-Terrorism
- Statement on the Cabinet meeting of 18 October 2023 (opens another site)Department of International Relations and Cooperation, South Africa
- Advisory opinion of 19 July 2024 on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, paragraph 94 (opens another site)International Court of Justice, published by the United Nations
- Israel claims it is no longer occupying the Gaza Strip. What does international law say? (opens another site)Atlantic Council
- Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I), 8 June 1977, Article 51(2) (opens another site)Text published by the United Nations
- United Nations Security Council resolution 1566 (2004) (opens another site)United Nations Security Council, text published by Wikisource
- Hamas: A Document of General Principles and Policies (2017), paragraph 1 (opens another site)Text published by Middle East Eye
- The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, 18 August 1988, Article 13 (opens another site)Avalon Project, Yale Law School
- General Assembly resolution 37/43, 3 December 1982, paragraph 2 (opens another site)United Nations
- Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 (Protocol I), 8 June 1977, Article 1(4) (opens another site)Text published by the International Committee of the Red Cross
- What does the law say about the responsibilities of the Occupying Power in the occupied Palestinian territory? (opens another site)International Committee of the Red Cross
- October 7 crimes against humanity, war crimes by Hamas-led groups (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Gaza: Hamas, Israel committed war crimes, claims independent rights probe (opens another site)UN News, United Nations
- Israeli authorities, Palestinian armed groups are responsible for war crimes, other grave violations of international law, UN Inquiry finds (opens another site)Independent International Commission of Inquiry, published by the United Nations
- Gaza/Israel: Hamas rocket attacks on civilians unlawful (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Erased in a moment: suicide bombing attacks against Israeli civilians, chapter IV (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
- Report of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry (A/HRC/56/26) (opens another site)Independent International Commission of Inquiry, published by the United Nations
- Hamas says October 7 attack was a ‘necessary step’, admits to ‘some faults’ (opens another site)Al Jazeera
- ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrants for Israeli PM Netanyahu and Hamas leaders (opens another site)BBC News
- Designation of foreign terrorist organizations, Federal Register, 8 October 1997 (opens another site)United States Department of State
- Home Secretary to ban Hamas from UK (opens another site)Home Office, United Kingdom
- General Assembly reiterates call for Middle East peace after failing to pass resolution condemning Hamas (opens another site)United Nations, meetings coverage
- Margaret Thatcher branded ANC ‘terrorist’ while urging Nelson Mandela’s release (opens another site)The Independent
- Kerry, Corker, Whitehouse announce Nelson Mandela will be removed from terror watch lists (opens another site)Office of Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, United States Senate
Report an error or suggest a source on this page →
Change history
- The Red Cross’s view that Gaza remained occupied (b15) shown as its position.
- Hamas’s own account of the attack (b8) shown as Hamas’s position, as on the 7 October page. Rights organisations’ documents classed as such ("other"), not as advocacy, as on every page.
- Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two.
- The statement giving Hamas’s account of 7 October now opens by saying it is Hamas’s own account.
- First published.