Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 7 · The war in Gaza · question 4 of 4

Who is responsible for the suffering of Gaza’s civilians, and to what extent?

Last reviewed

In brief

Argued in support of Israel’s position

Hamas bears the main responsibility: it started the war, fought from among civilians, and put its fighters before the people it governs.

The law tells every party to keep its forces away from civilians, and Hamas did the opposite: a United Nations inquiry noted reports of tunnels under civilian buildings and of hospitals, schools and mosques used for war, and of Hamas obstructing evacuations, weapons were found in UN schools in 2014, and a Hamas leader said the tunnels were built to protect fighters, not civilians. Hamas has also killed Gazans itself, executing people it calls collaborators and crushing dissent. It started the war on 7 October 2023, and could have ended it by freeing the hostages and laying down its arms.

Where this is argued: [1]Letter from the Permanent Representative of Israel to the United Nations, S/2023/858(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

Israel bears the main responsibility: it decides what is bombed and what enters Gaza, and nothing Hamas does releases it from the law.

The law says one party’s violations never release the other, and the UN inquiry that noted Hamas’s use of civilian buildings said so in the same paragraph. Israel’s defence minister announced that no electricity, food, water or fuel would enter Gaza; the International Criminal Court found reasonable grounds to charge him and Israel’s prime minister with starvation as a method of warfare; famine was confirmed in the Gaza governorate in 2025. A US review found no evidence of systematic theft by Hamas of US-funded aid, and a UN inquiry found that Israel’s forces restricted aid knowing civilians would be harmed. Gaza had already lived under blockade for sixteen years.

Where this is argued: [2]Israel: Starvation Used as Weapon of War in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)

What it turns on: The sources on this page show that the law of war binds each party whatever the other does, that Hamas and other armed groups have fought from within Gaza’s towns, and that Israel has controlled the bombardment and most of the crossings into Gaza. The sides disagree on how responsibility for the harm to civilians is shared between the party that fights from among them and the party that attacks, and on whose decisions best explain the deaths, the hunger, and the length of the war.

A note on terms

In the law of war, “human shields” means using civilians, or their movements, to protect military targets from attack. Placing fighters or weapons in or near civilian areas is covered by a separate rule, which asks parties to avoid it “to the maximum extent feasible”. On this page, a statement that uses the phrase says, or shows by its source, which of the two it means. [3]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions (Protocol I), 1977, Article 51(7)(opens another site in a new tab)

The restrictions Israel imposed on Gaza from June 2007, after Hamas took control of the territory, are called a “blockade” by the United Nations, a “closure” or security measures by Israel, and a “siege” by many Palestinians. Egypt controls the Rafah crossing and kept it closed for long periods. In October 2023 Israel’s defence minister announced a total cut-off, which differed from the restrictions before it. [4]Gaza Strip: The humanitarian impact of 15 years of the blockade, June 2022(opens another site in a new tab)[5]Israel's Defense Minister announces total siege of Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)

Counts of the dead come from Gaza’s Ministry of Health, run by Hamas, which does not separate fighters from civilians, though it has identified most of the dead as women or children; from Israel’s military, a party to the war, which does not publish its methods; and from United Nations offices, which count only the deaths they have been able to verify themselves. Counts of aid come from Israel, the United Nations, and aid organisations, and measure different things. Each figure on this page says whose it is. [6]Israel military reported to accept death toll of around 70,000 in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)

Point by point

Point 1 of 7

What does the law say each party owes civilians?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Israeli government

    Israel told the United Nations Security Council in November 2023 that Hamas’s military use of civilian areas, hospitals, schools and shelters “is undoubtedly the single greatest threat to the safety of Palestinian civilians in Gaza”.

    [1]Letter from the Permanent Representative of Israel to the United Nations, S/2023/858(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions requires the parties to a conflict, “to the maximum extent feasible”, to “avoid locating military objectives within or near densely populated areas”, and forbids using civilians to shield military objectives from attack. Israel is not a party to the Protocol; both sides treat these rules as binding customary law.

    [3]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions (Protocol I), 1977, Article 51(7)(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    The defender chooses where its fighters, tunnels and rockets go. A defender that puts them among civilians, when it could do otherwise, bears the main moral responsibility for the civilians killed when they are lawfully attacked. The attacker keeps its own duties of distinction, proportionality and precaution, and answers for any attack that breaks them.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    Additional Protocol I states that violations of its rules protecting civilians, including the ban on human shields, “shall not release the Parties to the conflict from their legal obligations with respect to the civilian population and civilians, including the obligation to take the precautionary measures”.

    [3]Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions (Protocol I), 1977, Article 51(7)(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    The UN commission that noted reports of Hamas’s use of civilian buildings said it had been unable to verify the evidence Israel’s forces presented, and that Israel’s forces remain bound by “the principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution in attacks”.

    [7]Detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from 7 October to 31 December 2023 (A/HRC/56/CRP.4)(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    Even where Hamas has used a building for war, that does not license an indiscriminate or disproportionate attack, or the cutting off of food. The party that drops the bomb, orders the evacuation and closes the crossing answers for that harm, whatever Hamas answers for its own conduct. Hamas’s breaches are separate wrongs, not a defence for Israel.

Point 2 of 7

How has Hamas used civilian areas, and what follows from it?

The findings on this point, from UN bodies and United States intelligence, concern armed groups’ use of civilian sites; the Palestinian side’s answer rests on denials and on what that evidence does not show, rather than on findings of its own.

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Position ·Mousa Abu Marzouk

    Mousa Abu Marzouk, a senior Hamas leader, said in an interview with Russia Today on 27 October 2023, as quoted by Israel to the Security Council, that “the tunnels in Gaza were built to protect Hamas fighters, not civilians”. The Arabic original is not quoted here.

    [1]Letter from the Permanent Representative of Israel to the United Nations, S/2023/858(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    A United Nations commission of inquiry, which could not verify Israel’s evidence, took note in 2024 of reports that Hamas and other armed groups “have built tunnels underneath civilian structures, utilized civilian structures such as some hospitals, schools and mosques for military purposes at times and fired rockets on some occasions from locations near civilian residential areas”. It said that in doing so they had put civilians in harm’s way, as those sites “may lose their protected status”. It also documented several reports that evacuations were “hindered by Hamas threats”.

    [7]Detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from 7 October to 31 December 2023 (A/HRC/56/CRP.4)(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Factual claim

    In July 2014 the UN agency for Palestinian refugees found about 20 rockets hidden in one of its vacant schools in Gaza, and the UN Secretary-General expressed “outrage” at the placing of weapons in a UN school. A UN board of inquiry later found it “likely that such a group may have fired the mortar from within the premises” of another school.

    [8]UNRWA strongly condemns placement of rockets in school(opens another site in a new tab)[9]Secretary-General’s statement on weapons found in an UNRWA school in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)[10]Secretary-General’s summary of the report of the UN Board of Inquiry on incidents in Gaza, 8 July to 26 August 2014(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·White House

    The White House said in November 2023 that United States intelligence showed Hamas “was using Al-Shifa as a command-and-control node”, at Gaza’s largest hospital.

    [11]US ‘still convinced’ Hamas used Al-Shifa as command center as Israeli raid continues(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    Tunnels under civilian buildings, weapons in schools, a hospital used as a command post on the United States’ account: this is a way of fighting chosen by Hamas and its allies, and it is what turns attacks on military targets into the deaths of civilians.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The White House presented no evidence for its statement about al-Shifa.

    [12]White House says intelligence shows Hamas using al-Shifa hospital for command node, storing weapons(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Doctors in Gaza

    Doctors in Gaza have always denied Israel’s claim that militants built tunnel infrastructure under the hospital.

    [12]White House says intelligence shows Hamas using al-Shifa hospital for command node, storing weapons(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Interpretation

    Gaza is one of the most crowded places on earth, and its people have had almost no way out. Fighting there is not the same as using civilians as shields, and treating every bombed building as proof of shielding erases the attacker’s duties.

Point 3 of 7

What harm has Hamas done to Gazans directly?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    A United Nations inquiry found that 21 people accused of collaborating with Israel were executed in Gaza in August 2014. In September 2025 BBC Verify confirmed the location of footage showing the public execution of three men accused of collaboration, outside al-Shifa hospital.

    [13]Report of the independent commission of inquiry established pursuant to Human Rights Council resolution S-21/1(opens another site in a new tab)[14]Footage shows public executions in Gaza City street(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Position ·Human Rights Watch

    Human Rights Watch reported in 2018 that the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, where they have autonomy, “have developed parallel police states”, with arbitrary arrests and torture of critics that it called systematic.

    [15]Palestine: Authorities Crush Dissent(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Factual claim

    Human Rights Watch found that the explosion at al-Ahli hospital on 17 October 2023 was caused by “an apparent rocket-propelled munition, such as those commonly used by Palestinian armed groups”, and said that further investigation was needed to determine who launched it.

    [16]Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Israeli army

    Israel’s military said that 7.52 per cent of the rockets fired from Gaza in the war’s first eleven days failed to reach Israeli territory.

    [17]IDF: At least 450 terror rockets fell short in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    Executions, repression and the obstruction of evacuations are harms Hamas has done to Gazans itself. They show a movement that treats the people it governs as expendable, which is also how it fights.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The UN human rights office was unable to say who caused the explosion at al-Ahli hospital. The State of Palestine says it was caused by a missile strike; Israel attributes it to a rocket fired by Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

    [18]Thematic report: Attacks on hospitals during the escalation of hostilities in Gaza (7 October 2023 – 30 June 2024)(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Where Hamas has killed or repressed Gazans, it answers for it. But on this view those crimes do not explain the scale of the deaths, the displacement and the hunger, which follow Israeli fire and Israeli control of the crossings.

Point 4 of 7

How has Israel waged the war, and what follows from it?

The findings on this point, from the International Criminal Court’s judges, the UN commission of inquiry and the UN human rights office, concern Israel’s conduct; Israel’s side answers with its stated policies and its reading of the war, rather than with findings of its own.

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Interpretation

    A high death toll is the foreseeable result of a war against an enemy fighting from underground and from civilian buildings. Israel’s evacuation orders were meant to move civilians out of harm’s way, as the law asks; the number of dead alone does not show that Israel abandoned the rules.

  2. Position ·Israeli army

    Israel’s military told CBS News that it prohibits the use of human shields.

    [19]Israeli soldier tells CBS News he was ordered to use Palestinians as human shields in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Benjamin Netanyahu

    Prime Minister Netanyahu called the International Criminal Court’s accusations of November 2024 “absurd and false”.

    [20]ICC issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant, Deif(opens another site in a new tab)

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    Israel’s defence minister, Yoav Gallant, announced on 9 October 2023: “There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel, it’s all closed.”

    [5]Israel's Defense Minister announces total siege of Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    The International Criminal Court found reasonable grounds in November 2024 to believe that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant bear criminal responsibility “for the war crime of starvation as a method of warfare”, having “intentionally and knowingly deprived the civilian population in Gaza of objects indispensable to their survival”.

    [20]ICC issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant, Deif(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Israeli soldier, unnamed

    An Israeli soldier told CBS News in 2025 that his commander ordered his unit “to use Gazan civilians to search buildings for explosives instead of dogs”.

    [19]Israeli soldier tells CBS News he was ordered to use Palestinians as human shields in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Factual claim

    The UN human rights office recorded at least 875 killings near aid sites and food convoys in six weeks in mid-2025, most of them close to the distribution points of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation.

    [21]Crush at Gaza aid site kills at least 20, GHF blames armed agitators(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Factual claim

    Gaza’s Ministry of Health counts more than 20,000 children killed by Israeli forces since October 2023.

    [22]One year after ceasefire announcement, killings continue across Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)

    Only source: a party to the conflict (Gaza’s Ministry of Health, under the Hamas-run administration)

  6. Position ·UN Commission of Inquiry

    The UN commission of inquiry found that Israel’s forces “blocked and restricted entry of humanitarian aid and assistance into the Gaza Strip with the knowledge and intention that the civilian population will be harmed”, and that they attacked areas they had designated as safe, knowing civilians were there.

    [7]Detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from 7 October to 31 December 2023 (A/HRC/56/CRP.4)(opens another site in a new tab)
  7. Interpretation

    The words of Israel’s leaders, the court’s findings, the deaths at aid sites and the soldiers’ own accounts show that the harm to civilians was the result of Israeli choices, not an unavoidable side effect of fighting a hidden enemy.

Point 5 of 7

Who is responsible for hunger and the shortage of aid?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The Inspector General of the United States aid agency said in July 2025 that it was investigating “credible allegations of Hamas interference, diversion, and theft of humanitarian aid in Gaza”. In February 2009 Hamas’s social affairs ministry confiscated ten trucks of UN food aid, which it later returned.

    [23]USAID OIG’s Gaza-related oversight work(opens another site in a new tab)[24]Humanitarian situation in Gaza, confiscation of UNRWA aid, ceasefire violations: field update from the Humanitarian Coordinator(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    As the authority in Gaza, Hamas has had the power to seize aid, as it did in 2009, and to control its distribution. Whatever the exact share it has taken, the allegations now under US investigation show it is a cause of hunger, not only its victim.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    An internal US government analysis found “no evidence of systematic theft by the Palestinian militant group Hamas of U.S.-funded humanitarian supplies”. It found that at least 44 of the 156 incidents of stolen or lost aid it examined were due, directly or indirectly, to Israeli military actions.

    [25]USAID analysis found no evidence of massive Hamas theft of Gaza aid(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Factual claim

    The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, the UN-backed hunger monitor, confirmed famine in the Gaza governorate as of 15 August 2025. Prime Minister Netanyahu confirmed in June 2025 that Israel was arming clans in Gaza opposed to Hamas.

    [26]UN declares famine in Gaza, first ever in Middle East(opens another site in a new tab)[27]Netanyahu confirms Israel arming clans opposed to Hamas in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  3. Position ·Human Rights Watch

    Human Rights Watch concluded in December 2023 that “the Israeli government is using starvation of civilians as a method of warfare in the Gaza Strip”.

    [2]Israel: Starvation Used as Weapon of War in Gaza(opens another site in a new tab)
  4. Position ·Keir Starmer

    In July 2025 the British prime minister spoke of “the pressing need for Israel to change course and allow the aid that is desperately needed to enter Gaza”.

    [28]PM statement on Gaza: 24 July 2025(opens another site in a new tab)
  5. Interpretation

    The party that decides how many trucks cross and what fuel and water enter bears responsibility for hunger. Theft by gangs does not shift that responsibility, and the one US review of US-funded aid found no evidence of the systematic theft by Hamas that Israel alleges.

Point 6 of 7

What were conditions in Gaza before the war, and why?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The UN humanitarian office records that in June 2007, “following the military takeover of Gaza by Hamas, the Israeli authorities significantly intensified existing movement restrictions”, and that Egypt closed the Rafah crossing “for long periods after 2014”.

    [4]Gaza Strip: The humanitarian impact of 15 years of the blockade, June 2022(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    The restrictions were a security response to a hostile armed group that had seized the territory and fired rockets at Israeli towns, and Egypt imposed its own. Hamas chose to spend what entered on tunnels and rockets rather than on shelters for civilians.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    The UN humanitarian office recorded in 2008 that Israel had “intensified to an unprecedented level the blockade on the Gaza Strip, imposed in June 2007”, and in 2016 that 1.9 million Palestinians in Gaza were “locked in”, unable to reach the rest of the Palestinian territory or the outside world.

    [29]Gaza humanitarian situation report, 15 December 2008(opens another site in a new tab)[30]Gaza blockade fact sheet, November 2016(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Sixteen years of blockade made Gaza dependent on aid and left its people nowhere to go when the war came. Hamas’s misrule does not turn that closure into a neutral security measure.

Point 7 of 7

Who started the war, and who has prolonged it?

Argued in support of Israel’s position

  1. Factual claim

    The war began when Hamas-led fighters entered Israel on 7 October 2023, killing 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages to Gaza, by Israeli counts. The International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for Hamas’s military chief, Mohammed Deif, in the same decision as for Israel’s leaders.

    [31]Israel sends tanks into Gaza’s Deir al-Balah, raising concerns among hostages’ families(opens another site in a new tab)[20]ICC issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant, Deif(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Hamas started the war and could have ended it at any point by freeing the hostages and laying down its arms. Proposals that would have left it armed and in power were proposals Israel was entitled to refuse.

Argued in support of the Palestinian position

  1. Factual claim

    In July 2024 Israel sought changes to a plan for a truce and the release of hostages, complicating a final deal, according to a Western official, a Palestinian source and two Egyptian sources cited by Reuters.

    [32]Exclusive: Israel seeks changes to Gaza truce plan, complicating talks, sources say(opens another site in a new tab)
  2. Interpretation

    Starting a war does not decide how it may be fought. Israel, too, held out for changes to the terms of a truce, and its choice to pursue its campaign at this scale is what prolonged the harm to Gaza’s civilians.

Sources

  1. Letter from the Permanent Representative of Israel to the United Nations, S/2023/858 (opens another site)United Nations Security Council
  2. Israel: Starvation Used as Weapon of War in Gaza (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
  3. Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions (Protocol I), 1977, Article 51(7) (opens another site)International Committee of the Red Cross
  4. Gaza Strip: The humanitarian impact of 15 years of the blockade, June 2022 (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
  5. Israel's Defense Minister announces total siege of Gaza (opens another site)Globes
  6. Israel military reported to accept death toll of around 70,000 in Gaza (opens another site)Reuters, published by Al-Monitor
  7. Detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from 7 October to 31 December 2023 (A/HRC/56/CRP.4) (opens another site)UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory
  8. UNRWA strongly condemns placement of rockets in school (opens another site)UNRWA, archived by the Internet Archive
  9. Secretary-General’s statement on weapons found in an UNRWA school in Gaza (opens another site)United Nations
  10. Secretary-General’s summary of the report of the UN Board of Inquiry on incidents in Gaza, 8 July to 26 August 2014 (opens another site)United Nations
  11. US ‘still convinced’ Hamas used Al-Shifa as command center as Israeli raid continues (opens another site)ABC News
  12. White House says intelligence shows Hamas using al-Shifa hospital for command node, storing weapons (opens another site)CNN, via WRAL
  13. Report of the independent commission of inquiry established pursuant to Human Rights Council resolution S-21/1 (opens another site)United Nations Human Rights Council
  14. Footage shows public executions in Gaza City street (opens another site)BBC News
  15. Palestine: Authorities Crush Dissent (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
  16. Gaza: Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion (opens another site)Human Rights Watch
  17. IDF: At least 450 terror rockets fell short in Gaza (opens another site)Jewish News Syndicate
  18. Thematic report: Attacks on hospitals during the escalation of hostilities in Gaza (7 October 2023 – 30 June 2024) (opens another site)UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
  19. Israeli soldier tells CBS News he was ordered to use Palestinians as human shields in Gaza (opens another site)CBS News
  20. ICC issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant, Deif (opens another site)Agence France-Presse, via JusticeInfo.net
  21. Crush at Gaza aid site kills at least 20, GHF blames armed agitators (opens another site)Reuters, via MarketScreener
  22. One year after ceasefire announcement, killings continue across Gaza (opens another site)UN Human Rights Office, published by the United Nations in Palestine
  23. USAID OIG’s Gaza-related oversight work (opens another site)Office of Inspector General, US Agency for International Development
  24. Humanitarian situation in Gaza, confiscation of UNRWA aid, ceasefire violations: field update from the Humanitarian Coordinator (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
  25. USAID analysis found no evidence of massive Hamas theft of Gaza aid (opens another site)Reuters, via MarketScreener
  26. UN declares famine in Gaza, first ever in Middle East (opens another site)Agence France-Presse, via JusticeInfo.net
  27. Netanyahu confirms Israel arming clans opposed to Hamas in Gaza (opens another site)BBC News
  28. PM statement on Gaza: 24 July 2025 (opens another site)Prime Minister’s Office, United Kingdom
  29. Gaza humanitarian situation report, 15 December 2008 (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
  30. Gaza blockade fact sheet, November 2016 (opens another site)UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
  31. Israel sends tanks into Gaza’s Deir al-Balah, raising concerns among hostages’ families (opens another site)Reuters, via MarketScreener
  32. Exclusive: Israel seeks changes to Gaza truce plan, complicating talks, sources say (opens another site)Reuters, via MarketScreener

All the sources this site uses →

Change history

  • The note on figures now says, with its source, that Gaza's Ministry of Health has identified most of the dead as women or children, as the genocide page does.
  • Israel’s army’s statement on human shields (a14) shown as its position. The UN count of killings near aid sites and the Health Ministry’s count of children killed are now separate statements, the second noting that a party to the conflict is its only source (b11, b24). The doctors’ denial about al-Shifa is now a position of its own (b25).
  • Rights organisations’ documents classed as such ("other"), not as advocacy, as on every page.
  • Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two, and Israel’s answer to the International Criminal Court now stands in its own column.
  • Statements reporting what a government, an organisation, a scholar or a witness says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; statements quoting two speakers are split in two.
  • Added notes on the evidence under the points on Hamas’s use of civilian areas and on how Israel has waged the war.
  • Refine claim title.
  • First published.