Israeli–Palestinian conflict · Chapter 1 · The land and its peoples
Who is indigenous to the land, and what claim does that give?
Last reviewed
In brief
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
Palestinians are the land’s indigenous people: they lived on it, as its majority, for centuries, and Zionism is settler colonialism that displaced them.
Palestinians descend largely from the land’s earlier inhabitants, and they were its settled majority when Zionism began: the first British census counted 590,890 Muslims and 73,024 Christians to 83,794 Jews. Being indigenous means that continuous presence and its loss, not who came first, and archaeology finds that the early Israelites were themselves mostly Canaanites. Palestinian identity is modern but genuine, like every national identity. Zionism organised immigration to build a state in a land whose people did not consent, which is what settler colonialism means.
Where this is argued: [1]The Palestinian National Charter, Article 4(opens another site in a new tab)[2]A Logic of Elimination: historian Lorenzo Veracini discusses settler colonialism, Zionism, and decolonial futures (interview by Abe Silberstein)(opens another site in a new tab)[3]Palestinians are Indigenous. Here’s why that’s beside the point(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
The Jewish people is indigenous to the land: it took shape there, never wholly left it, and Zionism is its return.
The earliest record of Israel places it in Canaan more than three thousand years ago, and a genetic study traces most Jewish communities of the diaspora to the Levant. Jewish life went on in the land after the Roman wars, in Tiberias and later in Safed. The League of Nations recognised “the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine”. Zionism, on this view, was a people coming home, not settlers from a mother country, and a separate Palestinian nationhood formed only in the twentieth century.
Where this is argued: [4]Statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs(opens another site in a new tab)
What it turns on: The sources on this page show that the people of ancient Israel took shape in this land, that Arabic-speaking Muslims and Christians were the large majority when Zionism began, and that genetic studies find deep regional ancestry in Jews and in Palestinians alike. The sides weigh these facts differently: whether a people is indigenous to the land where it took shape, or to the land it lived on and lost; whether both peoples can be; and what being indigenous gives.
A note on terms
“The land” means the territory of the British Mandate for Palestine, which Israelis commonly call the Land of Israel and Palestinians call Palestine. “Israelites” are the ancient people; “Jews” are the people and the religion that descend from them; “Israelis” are citizens of the State of Israel, not all of them Jewish. Both national movements took shape between the late nineteenth and the early twentieth century, whatever the age of each people’s roots.
There is no agreed definition of “indigenous”. The 2007 United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples sets out rights but does not define who holds them, and the two sides emphasise different criteria. Genetic studies describe patterns of ancestry in groups, not the identity of any person, and ancestry is not the same thing as nationhood. [5]United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Article 10(opens another site in a new tab)
The name “Palestine” comes from the Philistines, a people who reached the coast in the twelfth century BCE. Ancient DNA from Ashkelon shows that the European-related ancestry they brought “was subsequently diluted by the local Levantine gene pool over the succeeding centuries”. The name and the study do not settle who is indigenous today. [6]Ancient DNA sheds light on the origins of the Biblical Philistines (on Feldman et al., Science Advances)(opens another site in a new tab)[7]Ancient DNA sheds light on the genetic origins of early Iron Age Philistines (Feldman et al., Science Advances 5:7, 2019)(opens another site in a new tab)
Point by point
Point 1 of 5
What makes a people indigenous?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Interpretation
A people is indigenous because it has lived on a land continuously and lost it to newcomers, not because its distant ancestors were there first. Palestinians were the settled majority when Zionism began, and they were displaced by it.
- Position ·Azmi Bishara
The Palestinian scholar Azmi Bishara describes Palestinians as “an Indigenous native people who had already developed a national consciousness and polity before being exposed to ‘politicide’ and expulsion by a form of settler colonialism”.
[3]Palestinians are Indigenous. Here’s why that’s beside the point(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The first census of the British Mandate, in 1922, counted 757,182 people: 590,890 Muslims, 73,024 Christians and 83,794 Jews.
[8]1922 census of Palestine(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Position ·Israeli government
Its Foreign Ministry, in August 2025: “The Jewish people are the indigenous people of the Land of Israel.”
[4]Statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
A people is indigenous to the land where it took shape. The Jewish people’s language, religion, calendar and holy places all formed in this land, and exile did not break that bond. That bond does not depend on denying that others have lived there for centuries.
Point 2 of 5
Where did each people come from?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
A 2020 study of ancient DNA from the region found that a broader Near Eastern ancestry likely accounts “for more than 50 percent of the ancestry of many Arabic-speaking and Jewish groups living in the region today”, while the direct contribution of the Canaanites cannot be accurately measured.
[9]Genetic study sheds light on the origins of the Canaanites (on Agranat-Tamir et al., Cell)(opens another site in a new tab)[10]The Genomic History of the Bronze Age Southern Levant (Agranat-Tamir et al., Cell 181:5, 2020), abstract(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The Arab conquest of the seventh century changed the land’s rulers, its language and, over centuries, its main religion, far more than it changed its people. Palestinians descend largely from those who were already there, among them Jews and Christians who converted.
- Position ·William Dever
The archaeologist William Dever said in 1991: “The one thing we do all agree on—I think almost everyone does—is that somehow most of the early Israelites, or proto-Israelites, were indigenous Canaanites.”
[11]The Rise of Ancient Israel: panel discussion (Shanks, Dever, Halpern, McCarter), symposium at the Smithsonian Institution, 26 October 1991(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
If the Israelites arose from among the Canaanites, the story of Jews first and everyone else as latecomers falls apart. Ancestry three thousand years old gives no better title than centuries of living on the land.
- Position ·Palestine National Council
Its Palestinian National Charter of 1968 declares: “Claims of historical or religious ties of Jews with Palestine are incompatible with the facts of history and the true conception of what constitutes statehood.”
[1]The Palestinian National Charter, Article 4(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
The earliest known mention of Israel is on the victory stele of the Egyptian pharaoh Merneptah, which recounts his campaigns in Canaan: “Israel is laid waste, his seed is no more.”
[12]The Merneptah Stela: Israel Enters History(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
A genetic study published in Nature in 2010 traced “the origins of most Jewish Diaspora communities to the Levant”.
[13]The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people (Behar et al.)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Jewish life went on in the land after the Roman wars. From the second to the tenth century Tiberias was the largest Jewish city in Galilee, where much of the Mishnah and the Jerusalem Talmud were compiled. In 1555 twelve of the nineteen quarters of Safed were Jewish.
[14]Tiberias(opens another site in a new tab)[15]Safed(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Jews were never strangers to this land. Those who came from the 1880s onward joined Jewish communities already living there, in a land with which the people had kept a bond through every century of exile.
Point 3 of 5
Is Palestinian national identity genuine, and how old is it?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Position ·Palestine National Council
The same Charter states: “The Palestinian identity is a genuine, essential, and inherent characteristic; it is transmitted from parents to children.”
[1]The Palestinian National Charter, Article 4(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
The name was in use under Ottoman rule: Arabic newspapers in Palestine used the term “Filasṭīnī” about 170 times in more than 110 articles between 1908 and 1914, among them the Jaffa newspaper Filasṭīn, in 57 articles from 1911 to 1914. For the national identity, the historian Rashid Khalidi’s history of Palestinian identity places its formation in 1917–1923, in a chapter titled “The Formation of Palestinian Identity: The Critical Years, 1917–1923”.
[16]Emanuel Beška and Zachary Foster, The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late Ottoman Palestine, 1898–1914(opens another site in a new tab)[17]Rashid Khalidi, Palestinian Identity: The Construction of Modern National Consciousness, table of contents(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Zachary Foster
The historian Zachary Foster writes that under the Mandate “Palestinian”, and its Arabic equivalent, described any citizen, so that Zionists “did call themselves ‘Palestinian Jewry’” in English; “But the concept of a Palestinian people, in contrast to a Palestinian civic identity, had never included Zionists”: it “was a term reserved for the Arabic-speaking peoples of Palestine”.
[18]Zachary J. Foster, What’s a Palestinian?(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Modern does not mean invented. Every national identity is modern, Israel’s included: Zionism itself dates from the 1880s. Zuheir Mohsen spoke for one faction aligned with Syria, not for the Palestinian national movement.
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Position ·Golda Meir
In 1969, as Israel’s prime minister, to The Sunday Times: “There were no such thing as Palestinians. When was there an independent Palestinian people with a Palestinian state?”
[19]Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, Volume IX, Arab-Israeli Dispute, August 1978–December 1980, Document 218, note 3 (quoting The Sunday Times, 15 June 1969)(opens another site in a new tab) - Factual claim
Under the British Mandate, “Palestinian” was a citizenship that Jews held as well as Arabs: a UN mission wrote in 1949 that Jews and Arabs “had the same status with regard to Palestine citizenship under the Mandate”. Britain’s report to the League of Nations for 1925 recorded that the Palestinian Citizenship Order “facilitates the acquisition of citizenship by Jews”, and the daily that became Israel’s only English-language newspaper was called The Palestine Post until 1950, when it became The Jerusalem Post.
[20]Report by His Britannic Majesty's Government to the Council of the League of Nations on the Administration of Palestine and Trans-Jordan for the year 1925(opens another site in a new tab)[21]Letter from the Economic Survey Mission to the UN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, with memorandum on compensation, 22 November 1949(opens another site in a new tab)[22]“Palestine Post” Only English Newspaper in Israel, Renamed “Jerusalem Post”(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·James Gelvin
The historian James Gelvin writes: “Unlike the Zionists, Palestinians under the Ottomans had never been compelled to define themselves, and thus Palestinian nationalism emerged later than Zionism.” It became a mass movement, in his account, in the Great Revolt of 1936–39.
[23]James L. Gelvin, The Israel-Palestine Conflict: A History (4th edition), chapter “From Nationalism in Palestine to Palestinian Nationalism”, publisher’s summary(opens another site in a new tab) - Position ·Zuheir Mohsen
Zuheir Mohsen, leader of a Syrian-backed faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, told the Dutch newspaper Trouw in 1977, in an English translation of the interview, that “the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons”. How faithful that translation is has been disputed.
[24]Zuheir Mohsen(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
On this reading, the land’s Arabic-speaking inhabitants long identified first as Arabs, as Muslims or Christians, as Ottoman subjects, or with their town, and a separate Palestinian nation took shape only in the twentieth century, much of it in answer to Zionism. A national identity that recent cannot outrank the bond of the people that took shape on the land.
Point 4 of 5
Is Zionism a return or settler colonialism?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Position ·Lorenzo Veracini
The historian Lorenzo Veracini, a scholar of settler colonialism, says: “Zionism is a settler colonial movement and Israel is a settler colonial state.” He adds: “The Zionists were foreign to Palestine.”
[2]A Logic of Elimination: historian Lorenzo Veracini discusses settler colonialism, Zionism, and decolonial futures (interview by Abe Silberstein)(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Settler colonialism is defined by what a movement does, not by its ancestry: it brought immigrants under an imperial power’s protection to become a majority and found a state in a land whose people had not agreed. That is what Zionism did, wherever its people’s distant roots lay.
- Factual claim
The Balfour Declaration of 1917 viewed “with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people”, while pledging only that “nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine”. The Mandate of 1922 added that “the rights and position of other sections of the population” were not to be prejudiced. Neither named political rights for the land’s majority.
[25]The Balfour Declaration, 2 November 1917(opens another site in a new tab)[26]The Palestine Mandate, 24 July 1922, Article 6(opens another site in a new tab)
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Factual claim
In its preamble, the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine of 1922 records that recognition had been given “to the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine and to the grounds for reconstituting their national home in that country”.
[26]The Palestine Mandate, 24 July 1922, Article 6(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
Zionism was a return, not colonialism. No mother country sent the Jews or ruled through them; they came to the one land where they had a national history, and the League itself spoke of “reconstituting” their home.
Point 5 of 5
What does being indigenous give a people?
Argued in support of the Palestinian position
- Factual claim
The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples of 2007 states: “Indigenous peoples shall not be forcibly removed from their lands or territories.”
[5]United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Article 10(opens another site in a new tab) - Interpretation
The rights of a people living on its land, to stay, to take part in governing it, and to decide its future, do not depend on winning a contest over ancestry. Palestinians stand where the native peoples of the United States, Canada and Australia stood, except that their loss is recent, within living memory. An ancient tie cannot give one people the right to displace another.
Argued in support of Israel’s position
- Interpretation
Being indigenous gives a people a homeland, not a right to expel others: Jewish self-determination does not require denying the rights of Palestinians who live on the land. If displacing earlier inhabitants made a state illegitimate, the United States, Canada and Australia would be illegitimate too. Israel differs from them in the way that matters: its people took shape on the land it returned to.
Sources
- The Palestinian National Charter, Article 4 (opens another site)Palestine National Council, text published by the United Nations
- A Logic of Elimination: historian Lorenzo Veracini discusses settler colonialism, Zionism, and decolonial futures (interview by Abe Silberstein) (opens another site)Jewish Currents
- Palestinians are Indigenous. Here’s why that’s beside the point (opens another site)The New Arab
- Statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (opens another site)Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Israel, on X
- United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Article 10 (opens another site)United Nations
- Ancient DNA sheds light on the origins of the Biblical Philistines (on Feldman et al., Science Advances) (opens another site)Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History
- Ancient DNA sheds light on the genetic origins of early Iron Age Philistines (Feldman et al., Science Advances 5:7, 2019) (opens another site)Science Advances, via PubMed Central
- 1922 census of Palestine (opens another site)Wikipedia, summarising the Government of Palestine’s Report and General Abstracts of the Census of 1922
- Genetic study sheds light on the origins of the Canaanites (on Agranat-Tamir et al., Cell) (opens another site)Cell Press, via EurekAlert!
- The Genomic History of the Bronze Age Southern Levant (Agranat-Tamir et al., Cell 181:5, 2020), abstract (opens another site)Hebrew University of Jerusalem research portal
- The Rise of Ancient Israel: panel discussion (Shanks, Dever, Halpern, McCarter), symposium at the Smithsonian Institution, 26 October 1991 (opens another site)Biblical Archaeology Society Library
- The Merneptah Stela: Israel Enters History (opens another site)Biblical Archaeology Society Library
- The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people (Behar et al.) (opens another site)Nature
- Tiberias (opens another site)Wikipedia
- Safed (opens another site)Wikipedia
- Emanuel Beška and Zachary Foster, The Origins of the term “Palestinian” (“Filasṭīnī”) in late Ottoman Palestine, 1898–1914 (opens another site)Academia Letters
- Rashid Khalidi, Palestinian Identity: The Construction of Modern National Consciousness, table of contents (opens another site)Columbia University Press
- Zachary J. Foster, What’s a Palestinian? (opens another site)Foreign Affairs
- Foreign Relations of the United States, 1977–1980, Volume IX, Arab-Israeli Dispute, August 1978–December 1980, Document 218, note 3 (quoting The Sunday Times, 15 June 1969) (opens another site)Office of the Historian, US Department of State
- Report by His Britannic Majesty's Government to the Council of the League of Nations on the Administration of Palestine and Trans-Jordan for the year 1925 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- Letter from the Economic Survey Mission to the UN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, with memorandum on compensation, 22 November 1949 (opens another site)United Nations (UNISPAL)
- “Palestine Post” Only English Newspaper in Israel, Renamed “Jerusalem Post” (opens another site)Jewish Telegraphic Agency
- James L. Gelvin, The Israel-Palestine Conflict: A History (4th edition), chapter “From Nationalism in Palestine to Palestinian Nationalism”, publisher’s summary (opens another site)Cambridge University Press
- Zuheir Mohsen (opens another site)Wikiquote, quoting his interview with James Dorsey, Trouw, 31 March 1977
- The Balfour Declaration, 2 November 1917 (opens another site)The Avalon Project, Yale Law School
- The Palestine Mandate, 24 July 1922, Article 6 (opens another site)The Avalon Project, Yale Law School
Report an error or suggest a source on this page →
Change history
- The name 'Palestinian', raised by a reader: the Israeli column now gives the Mandate-era use of 'Palestinian' as a citizenship held by Jews as well as Arabs (a UN mission, Britain's 1925 report, The Palestine Post) and a historian, James Gelvin, who dates Palestinian nationalism later than Zionism; the Palestinian column gives Zachary Foster's answer that the concept of a Palestinian people was reserved for the Arabic-speaking population; the Arabic press's use of 'Filasṭīnī' before 1914 now rests on a scholarly study instead of Wikipedia; Golda Meir's 1969 statement is quoted in full, with her next sentence on statehood, from the US State Department's record; the mark on it stands, and its explanation now sets the civic use of the word apart from the people she denied.
- The genetic findings now cite the studies themselves, the 2020 study in Cell and the 2019 study in Science Advances, beside the institutions’ summaries. Raised by a reader.
- The evidence on Palestinian identity now separates the name from the national identity: the newspaper Falastin shows the name in use from 1911, and Rashid Khalidi dates the national identity to 1917–1923 (b10, and the mark on a7). Raised by a reader.
- Statements reporting what a government, an organisation or a scholar says are now shown as that speaker’s position, with the speaker named; the line on the 1922 Mandate now quotes its preamble.
- Replaced the copy of Lorenzo Veracini's interview with its original publication in Jewish Currents (January 2022).
- Removed the “misleading” mark on Lorenzo Veracini’s statement: whether ancient ties make Zionism something other than settler colonialism is a matter of interpretation, which this site does not rule on.
- First published.